SOCIETY FOR
THE SCIENTFIC STUDY OF READING
June 12 – June 15, 2003
The Renaissance Suites at Flatiron
Boulder, Colorado
ABSTRACTS
Marilyn Jager Adams
(Harvard University Graduate School of Education), Hollis Scarborough, and Linda Fidell. On students, teachers, instruction, and reading reform: Findings from
California's K-3 results database. California's
K-3 Results program is a statewide reading reform initiative, conceived,
managed, and operated entirely by classroom teachers. Its core design principle
is one of using skill-specific classroom assessments as foundation for
promoting professional development and improving student outcomes. Asked to
evaluate the program by the Stuart Foundation, we have compiled a database that
links performance on beginning-, middle-, and end-of-year classroom
assessments, SAT9 scores, instructional programs and materials, and a range of
background information on individual students, teachers, classrooms, and schools.
In all, the database includes records for more than 20,000 teachers and 200,000
students across 5 school years (1996-97 to 2000-01), enabling both longitudinal
and cross-section examination of the efficacy of the Program and of a number of
the role of a number of factors that modulate K-3 reading success and
difficulty.
Stephanie Al Otaiba
(Florida State University), Marcia Grek, and Joseph Torgesen. Core basal reading instruction as
"primary intervention": A review of basal beginning reading programs
for reading first schools. This
session describes a review process to select beginning reading basal curriculum
(K-1) that are consistent with scientifically based reading research and with
the Reading First documents. Specifically, we will describe the process of
evaluating and selecting reading basal programs for Reading First Schools from
basal reading programs currently on the Florida state adoption list. We will
discuss, compare, and contrast curricula which are and are not in alignment
with Reading First guidance documents. Implications for professional
development will be discussed.
Jason L. Anthony
(University of Houston), Christopher J. Lonigan, and Christopher Schatschneider.
Investigating the dimensionality of
phonological sensitivity: An item response theory approach. Controversy exists concerning the nature of
phonological sensitivity (PS). One view holds different PS skills reflect
independent abilities; another suggests unidimensionality. Statistical methods
used to resolve the controversy have been compromised by commonplace
measurement problems. We employed a method less vulnerable to measurement
problems. Specifically, we examined the overlap of 18 PS skills in 1056 2- to
6-year-old children from diverse backgrounds. Modified parallel analysis
demonstrated all items indexed a single latent dimension. Information functions
from an Item Response Theory model illustrated important differences in how
informative the skills were along the ability continuum. Findings support a
unidimensional and developmental conceptualization of preschoolers'
phonological sensitivity that progresses from word sensitivity to phoneme
sensitivity and from synthesis to analysis.
Amanda C. Appleton
(Vanderbilt University), and Donald L. Compton. The effects of three different levels of decodability in text across
time on fluency and accuracy in 3rd, 4th, and 5th grade students experiencing
reading difficulties. Children
with reading difficulties spend less time reading and have significant
difficulties decoding words. Furthermore, when they are exposed to text they
read more difficult instructional materials for them than good readers.
Explicit instruction facilitates reading fluency; however, the contributions of
the components of text factors for augmenting fluency for students with reading
difficulties are less clear. The purpose of this study is to investigate the
effects of three different levels of decodability in informational text across
time on fluency and accuracy in 3rd, 4th, and 5th grade students who are experiencing
reading difficulties and who are receiving explicit reading instruction.
Alison Arrow (University
of Auckland), Claire M. Fletcher-Flinn, and Tom Nicholson. "That's my name": Early precursors to reading development. Recognising ones own name may be an underestimated
precursor to literacy development. The letters in one’s own name are those that
children appear to be able to identify first. The literacy knowledge of more
than 60 preschoolers (4.6 4.11) with no formal reading education was investigated.
The findings showed that all preschoolers had rime awareness available to them
regardless of own name recognition. However, children who could recognise their
own name had more letter name and sound knowledge, as well as increased phoneme
awareness.
Bettina Baker (University
of Pennsylvania), and William Labov. Unexpected
differences in reading error profiles among regional, ethnic and language
groups. Data were collected on
reading errors from 500 struggling readers in grades 2-4 in low income schools
in Pennsylvania and California, including African-American, Euro-American , and
Latinos. The results confirm for all groups that the major problems in decoding
are the result of incomplete knowledge of combinatory relations, but a number
of unexpected findings showed the influence of learning to read in Spanish
first.. A pilot intervention study had similar results for all groups in
improving decoding skills for many structures. However, some striking
consequences of language background emerged for the Latino children who learned
to read in Spanish first.
Karen Baker (Regional
Support Associates), Patricia Bowers, and Joel B. Talcott. Visual processes and the double deficit hypothesis for reading
disability. This study
explored the possible links between visual processing speed, naming speed and
reading disabilities as defined by the Double Deficit Hypothesis (Wolf &
Bowers, 1999). Eighty-one Grade Two children representing no deficit, single
and double deficit groups were administered a battery of reading and visual
processing tests. Results showed that, within this sample, early visual
processing, as assessed by the Coherent Motion task (Talcott, 2002), was highly
related to reading skill within a poor reader group but not across the sample.
Moreover, performance on the Coherent Motion task appeared to measure a unique
aspect of reading disability.
Michal Balass (University
of Pittsburgh), Jessica Nelson, and Charles A. Perfetti. Learning words: An event-related potentials study. An Event Related Potential (ERP) experiment compared
word processing and learning in different word training environments (semantic,
phonological, and orthographic). Subjects were taught rare words (e.g.
gloaming) in one of three conditions: Orthography to Phonology; Phonology to Meaning;
Orthography to Meaning. Following learning, they made meaning judgments about
words while their ERPs were recorded. ERP signals distinguished between rare
words and more familiar words, between learned and unknown rare words, and
among orthographic, phonological and semantic information that was provided in
training. The results demonstrate that ERPs not only provide distinctive
information about the three constituents of word representations, they also
provide signatures for word learning.
Cathy L. Barr (Hospital
for Sick Children), Karen Wigg, Yu Feng, Jill Couto, Barbara Anderson, Tasha
Cate, Rosemary Tannock, Marueen Lovett, and Tom Humphries. Recent progress in genetic studies of reading disabilities: Fine
mapping for gene identification in the 6p and 15q regions. Genetic linkage studies of specific reading
disabilities (RD) have found significant evidence for linkage to 6 chromosomal
regions. To identify genes contributing to the susceptibility to RD, we have
collected a sample of 120 families ascertained through a proband with RD. Our
studies of the 6p21.3 and 15q regions indicate that this sample of families are
linked to these regions. The most significant finding for the 6p21.3 region was
for markers located near the gene for myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein
(MOG), indicating that the genetic variant(s) contributing to RD is likely to
be very close to this gene.
Melissa Bell (University
of Toronto), and Esther Geva. Language
specific early predictors of reading difficulty in ESL children. English measures of phonological awareness,
word-reading, and reading comprehension were administered from kindergarten to
grade 3 in 12 Canadian schools on English as a Second language (ESL) children
whose first language (L1) was either Punjabi, or Portuguese. These two language
groups were studied because the L1’s include alphabetic and non-alphabetic
orthographies, different phonological and syntactic structures, and their
prevalence in the Canadian education system. It was hypothesized that different
phonological awareness tasks (onset/rime identification, syllable segmentation,
phoneme segmentation) will differentially predict difficulty on both
word-reading tasks and on reading comprehension tasks between the two ESL
groups. Understanding the nature of the specific phonological awareness
components that predict subsequent reading ability for specific language groups
is of theoretical interest as well as of educational/clinical importance.
Inez Berends (PI
Research, VU Amsterdam), and Pieter Reitsma. Lateral versus central presentation in repeated reading with limited
exposure times. Some
neuropsychological theories claim advantages for training procedures for
dyslexics in which words are briefly presented in the left or right visual
field. In two first training experiments with backward readers the effects of
location and of limited exposure duration are evaluated. Experiment 1 involved
25 slow, but accurate readers and presentation in either the left or right
visual field. Experiment 2 contrasted central versus lateral presentation, and
limited versus unlimited presentation duration in 36 delayed beginning readers.
No effects of position nor of presentation time were found, but repeated
reading appeared to be effective overall.
Rebecca S. Betjemann (University of Denver), Janice M. Keenan, and Richard K. Olson. Listening comprehension in children with
reading disability. We
investigated the contributions of word decoding, IQ, and listening
comprehension to deficits in reading comprehension for children with reading
disability. Results showed that subjects with reading disability are often
worse on both reading and listening comprehension compared to normal readers,
though the relative contributions of word decoding and listening comprehension
to reading comprehension varied with age. Stepwise regression analyses found
that younger subjects' reading comprehension was best predicted by decoding
ability, while older subjects' reading comprehension was best predicted by IQ
and listening comprehension. Listening comprehension was not a significant
predictor of reading comprehension after decoding and IQ.
Anne Bishop (University
of Florida), and Martha League. Prediction
of early reading achievement: Choosing the right children, ath the right time,
with the right instrument. Researchers
conducted a three-year study to determine the optimal combination of predictive
measures that correlate to early reading achievement. Letter identification,
phonological awareness, phonological memory, and rapid serial naming measures were
administered in fall and winter of kindergarten to determine if results varied
across time. Five predictive models were examined, based on current predictive
literature. These models were correlated with four measures of reading: word
reading skills, non-word reading skills, fluency, and comprehension. Results
are reported for reading achievement at the end of first and second grade.
Jeffrey L. Black
(Texas Scottish Rite Hospital for Children), and Jeremiah Ring. What happens after remediation? A follow-up
study of the Dyslexia Treatment Program. An
important theoretical and practical question in the field of dyslexia concerns
the stability of treatment effects and the transfer of skills and strategies to
literacy development following the conclusion of phonologically-based reading
interventions. This study examines treatment effects after completing the
Dyslexia Treatment Program, a standardized Orton-Gillingham based literacy
program. The follow-up data suggest that reading skills learned during the treatment
are stable one and two years after intervention. However, transfer of those
skills to continued literacy growth was only found in reading comprehension for
one year after intervention.
Regina Boulware-Gooden (Texas A&M University), Angelia Holcomb, Emily Ocker, and R. M.
Joshi. Expanding the evidence for the
comonential model of reading. In the 1991
report by the National Research Council a fluent reader will have adequate
skills in decoding, comprehension, and fluency. This finding was empirically supported
by the componential model of reading which is an extension of Gough’s simple
view of reading. The componential model of reading hypothesizes that reading
equals decoding multiplied by comprehension plus fluency. This model was
applied to Chall’s developmental stage model that children learn to read in
first through third and then read to learn fourth and above.
Kathleen J. Brown
(University of Utah Reading Clinic), Darrell Morris, Matthew Fields, Stacey
Lowe, Julie Robertson, Debbie Skidmore, Debbie Van Gorder, Connie Weinstein,
and Ursula Brock. The Virginia Model of
Intervention: Is it effective for English language learners? Can it be
delivered by supervised teachers' aides? The
current study replicates and extends findings from Brown et al. (2002) and
Morris et al. (1990) by indicating that the Virginia model of intervention is
effective for helping English Language Learners who are reading below grade
level expectations. Students who received Next Steps, an application of the
Virginia model for students above grade one, outperformed their control group
peers on all formal and informal measures. Similar results suggest that
para-professionals —under close supervision by an intervention specialist —can
also effectively deliver this intervention to English Language Learners who are
struggling readers.
Brian Byrne (University
of New England), Stefan Samuelsson, Sally Wadsworth, and Richard Olson. Longitudinal twin study of reading and
language: Preschool and kindergarten data. We
report an update on recently published behavior-genetic analyses of preschool
twins' performance on a variety of literacy, cognitive and linguistic variables
known to underpin reading growth. Genes appeared to influence phonological
awareness and aspects of learning, including acquiring phonemic awareness. In
contrast, shared environment affected vocabulary, grammar, morphology, and
print knowledge. We also report preliminary data on the kindergarten follow-up
of some of these twins, and on the growth from preschool to kindergarten. The
update, which includes twin data from Norway, confirms earlier conclusions. The
follow-up data indicate that genetic effects remain in evidence, but that
shared environment continues to exert significant influence on important
aspects of literacy development.
Donna Caccamise (University
of Colorado), Nicole Davis, Marita Franzke, Nina Johnson, Eileen Kintsch. Using LSA in the classroom: Implementing
Summary Street in grades 6 to 12. Summary
Street is an educational application of Latent Semantic Analysis (LSA), a
statistical method that enables computers to evaluate the meaning of texts in
ways that resemble humans. With Summary Street students can prepare multiple
drafts of a summary with feedback about the content adequacy of their
summaries, regardless of the particular words used. Multiple cycles of practice
in writing and revision are possible without increasing the teachers' workload.
In this study, transfer effects of summary street to independently collected
comprehension measures (CSAP) were assessed looking at changes in CSAP scores
by experimental condition(summary street vs word processor), ability level,
individual performance on summaries, and by specific CSAP items. Results show
improvement in CSAP scores for deep comprehension items for students using
summary street, particularly among the poorer ability levels.Claire Cameron (University of Michigan), Carol
McDonald Connor, and Jocelyn Petrella. Effect
of teacher organization on classroom functioning and children's reading
outcomes. This study examined the
effect of organizational time, a non-instructional variable, on the classroom
environment, looking particularly at amount of transition time and
child-independent work. Forty-four first-grade classrooms were observed at
three points over the school year (fall, winter, spring). Narratives were kept
of each activity that lasted longer than one minute.
"Orient-organize" referred to the amount of time teachers spent
orienting students to classroom procedures or organizing for specific assignments.
Meaningful variation in orient-organize time was observed, which predicted time
spent transitioning and in child-independent work. The effect of these
variables on reading outcomes will be discussed.
Joanne F. Carlisle
(University of Michigan), Kay Hanson, and Sarah Scott. The interrelation of phonological development and vocabulary knowledge
for beginning readers. While
models of children's phonological development generally portray vocabulary
development as a major influence on the specificity of phonological
representations and phonological awareness (e.g., Metsala & Walley's
Lexical Restructuring Model), research reports have not consistently reported a
significant association between vocabulary knowledge and phonological
awareness. This study examines (1) relations of different aspects of
phonological sensitivity and measures of word knowledge for beginning readers
and (2) the contribution of word knowledge, phonological development, and the
interaction of these two traits to their reading achievement. Results suggest
that lexical representations built on mutual reinforcement of sound-meaning
relations play a significant role in the early stages of learning to read.
Ronald P. Carver
(University of Missouri at Kansas City). The
role of orthographic processing speed in a causal model of reading achievement. A verbal aptitude test, called Verbal Level Aptitude
Test (VLAT), and a pronunciation aptitude test called Spelling Words Aptitude
Test (SWAT) have been developed to test components of a causal model of reading
achievement. These two tests, plus 8
other tests, were administered to 130 sixth and seventh graders in an urban
charter school. This data collection has just been completed. These data will
be analyzed prior to the annual meeting to see if there is correlational
evidence consistent with hypotheses regarding the theorized causal model, using
structural equation modeling.
Hugh W. Catts (University
of Kansas), Tiffany P. Hogan, Amy E. Barth, and Suzanne M. Adlof. The simple view of reading: Changes over
time. We identified a large sample
of children in kindergarten (N=600) and measured their reading achievement and
language/cognitive abilities in 2nd, 4th, and 8th grades. In this poster, we
consider the factors related to growth in word recognition and reading
comprehension abilities from kindergarten through 8th grade.
Xi Chen (University
of Illiois at Urbana-Champaign), and Richard C. Anderson. Transfer of phonological awareness in Cantonese children learning to
read Mandarin. Investigated
was the phonological awareness of first, second, and fourth grade children from
Guangzhou, China, who were native speakers of Cantonese and received immersion
Mandarin instruction at school. The study yielded three important findings. First,
phonological awareness in Cantonese and Mandarin are highly correlated, which
provides confirming evidence for the transfer of phonological awareness
previously found between Western languages. Second, two clear factors emerged
in a factor analysis, onset-rime awareness and tone awareness, while language
was not an independent factor. This indicates that onset-rime awareness and
tone awareness are the same constructs in the two languages. Third, children’s
development of phonological awareness is affected by both the phonological
structure of Cantonese and exposure to reading instruction in Mandarin.
Joanna Christodoulou (Tufts University), Maryanne Wolf, Maureen Lovett, and Robin Morris. Comprehension abilities and expressive and
receptive language profiles of three impaired-reader subtypes. The purpose of this study is to advance our
understanding of possible differences in the expressive and receptive language
skills and comprehension performance of three impaired-reader subtypes.
Participants were 257 children in Grades 2-3 identified as having severe
reading disabilities. Students were classified in subtypes based on the
performance on naming speed and phonological tasks. The relationships between
measures of expressive and receptive language and four measures of comprehension
will be studied for each subtype. Implications for diagnosis and intervention
are discussed.
Donald L. Compton
(Vanderbilt University), Amy Elleman, Natalie Olinghouse, Jan Vining, and
Amanda Appleton. Modeling individual
differences in skill generalization of children with reading disabilities
enrolled in a structured decoding program. Generalization
and transfer of gains in phonological processing and nonword decoding skills to
real word reading has turned out to be problematic for children with reading
disabilities (RD). One exception to this rule is the PHAST program developed by
Lovett and colleagues (Lovett, Lacerenza, & Borden, 2000). PHAST has been
shown to promote generalization of nonword decoding skills to real word
identification in children with RD. The degree of generalization, however, has
yet to be quantified. This study attempted to estimate individual differences
in decoding skill generalization in approximately 40 children with RD enrolled
in PHAST. To do this a theoretical word decoding curve was derived for the
PHAST program and individual growth curves of each child were compared to this
theoretical growth curve. The difference between an individual’s growth curve
and the theoretical growth curve is conceptualized as an individual measure of
skill generalization that is then used to predict individual growth on
standardized measures of reading skill during intervention.
Nicole Conrad (McMaster
University), and Betty Ann Levy. Training
letter and orthographic pattern recognition in children with slow RAN
performance. Children
with slow RAN performance participated in a training study that examined the
benefits of two components of reading. Training consisted of speeded letter
recognition followed by orthographic pattern recognition or the reverse. The
question was whether training improved the speed of letter identification, and
whether the effects of letter and orthographic training were additive. Results
highlighted the importance of repeated practice with orthographic units. Letter
naming speed improved only when preceded by orthographic pattern recognition
training. Letter recognition training provided no additional benefit to
orthographic training. Results are related to theories of the relationship
between RAN performance and reading.
Pierre Cormier (Université
de Moncton), Alain Desrochers, and Monique Sénéchal. The relative importance of syllabic awareness in word decoding skills:
evidence from native speakers of French. The
importance of syllabic structure in oral language is a feature that
distinguishes French from English. In our current research program targeting
the development of a battery of tests of reading skills in French, we examined
the relation of syllabic awareness to word and pseudoword decoding in French
across the elementary grades. Syllabic awareness was contrasted with letter
sound knowledge and phonemic awareness. A sample of 308 young French Canadian
readers from Kindergarten to Grade 6 were tested at the end of the school year
on measures of phonological and syllabic deletion, letter naming, grapheme
sounding, and oral reading of regular and irregular words. Descriptive findings
indicated that a) syllabic deletion was easier than phonological deletion at
all grade levels and performance increased steadily to reach about 90% at the
end of Grade 6, b) the names of over 95% of the 26 letters and the sounds of
over 80% of the 40 basic graphemes of French were known by the end of Grade 1
but sounding some of the graphemes was still difficult at the end of Grade 6; and
c) reading words and pseudowords aloud improved consistently across grade
levels. Regression analyses using grade level as a control and contrasting the
relation of syllabic awareness to that of letter sound knowledge and phonemic
awareness showed that syllabic awareness has a unique contribution to word, b =
.265, DR2 = .028, F (1, 265) = 39.43, p < .05, and pseudoword decoding, b =
.249, DR2 = .025, F (1, 263) = 20.23, p < .05. These effects of syllabic
awareness changed through time as indicated by significant interactions with
grade level for word, F (1, 264) = 17.74, p < .05, and pseudoword decoding,
F (1, 262) = 7.90, p < .05. For word decoding, the strength of the relation
of syllabic awareness became significant in grade 2 and waned in grade 5. That
pattern was different for pseudoword decoding as the relation of syllabic
awareness was significant only in grades 2 and 3. In contrast, phonemic
awareness was significant across almost all grade levels for word decoding and
all grade levels for pseudoword decoding. Although syllabic awareness appears
to be an important feature of learning to read in French, it does not preclude
the importance of phonemic awareness, one of the major contributors of learning
to read in English.
Kathleen Corriveau
(Harvard Graduate School of Education), Tami Katzir, Beth O'Brien, Robin
Morris, Maureen Lovett, and Maryanne Wolf. Timed
and untimed reading performance in subtypes of dyslexia. A primary question of this study involved the function
of limited response time in word and nonword identification tasks. In the
present study 160 severely impaired readers in second and third grade were
classified according to the Double-Deficit Hypothesis and assessed on four
nonword and word-level identification tasks, and a variety of fluency measures.
The results demonstrated that the subtypes showed differential accuracy scores
as a function of limited time, with naming-speed deficit dyslexics showing the
most sensitivity. Implications of these findings for research and practice are discussed.
Gail Coulter (University
of Colorado, Colorado Springs), and Bonnie Grossen. What works to raise the performance levels of middle schools serving
high-need students. Schools
serving high poverty communities (where half or more of the students are
performing in the bottom quartile) struggle to raise their schoolwide
performance. A model for successfully accelerating the acquisition of
standards, thereby raising scores, will be presented. Schools implementing this
model reduce the number of students in the bottom quartile by one-third to
one-half each year. The percentile for the mean raw score is raised 10 to 15
percentile points the first year. The factors of success in this model
emphasize a focus on the interaction between teachers and students as the key.
Consistent with this focus, a school needs carefully designed direct
instruction curricula, program-specific professional development, in-vitro
coaching, and continuous monitoring of progress and mastery.
Laurie E. Cutting
(Kennedy Krieder Institute), Jeanne Wilkins, Joanna G. B. Schafer, Abigail A.
Flower, James J. Pekar, Susan M. Courtney, Martha Bridge Denckla, and Stewart
Mostofsky. FMRI of sentence comprehension
in adults: Preliminary findings. FMRI has
been used to examine the neural mechanisms underlying sentence comprehension;
however, few studies have accounted for activation attributable to two
fundamental components of sentence comprehension, single word reading (SWR) and
working memory (WM). To address this issue, four normal adult readers completed
fMRI a sentence comprehension task that was alternated with either a SWR or a
WM task. Results indicated that activation was observed in bilateral occipital
lobe and middle and inferior temporal gyri (L>R) for both sentence
comprehension tasks. For the sentence comprehension vs. SWR contrast,
additional activation was observed in medial frontal gyrus; for the sentence
comprehension vs. WM contrast, additional activation was observed in frontal
operculum (L>R) and right cerebellum.
Mary E. Dahlgren
(Payne Education Center), Regina Boulware-Gooden, and R. Malatesha Joshi. Multisensory instruction: Can it prove
effective after elementary level? A
multisensory, explicit, systematic, structured approach was used in middle
school language arts classrooms for a one year period. A matched control school
used the standard language arts curriculum. All students were reading below the
50th percentile upon entering the program. Anovas were conducted for
vocabulary, spelling and comprehension and p values as well as effect sizes
reported. Results showed that the differences between the multisensory
treatment group and the control group were statistically significant. This
study gives further evidence for the use of a multisensory approach to teaching
reading and spelling beyond the elementary grades.
Claire Davis (Oxford
University), and Peter Bryant. A
longitudinal study on the impact of spelling rules on children's spelling and
reading of vowels. Our
longitudinal study examined the changes in young children’s use of the final e
rule in reading and spellings, and the causes underlying these developmental
changes. The 103 children were in Year-groups 2 (n=38), 3 (n=36) and 5 (n=29)
when first tested, and were tested again a year later. Results from cross-lagged
panel correlations revealed that in year-group 2, rote learning was the
pacemaker for rule learning in children’s spellings, and that the reading of
real words predicted later use of the rule in spellings. Results give support
for Frith’s theory of reading and spelling development.
Peter F. de Jong
(University of Amsterdam). Early
predictors of letter knowledge. Despite the
importance of letter knowledge for later reading, there seems little research
on the cognitive abilities that affect its development. In this study, we
examined the influence of phonological memory (nonword repetition) and rapid
naming (objects) on the development of letter knowledge. Participants were 77
Dutch children, which were followed from the start of their first kindergarten
year (age of 4.6) to the end of their second year. We found a substantial
effect of phonological memory and a small effect of rapid naming on the
development of letter knowledge. General language skills (vocabulary) did not
have an independent contribution.
Carolyn A. Denton
(University of Texas Health Science Center Houston), Jason L. Anthony, Patricia
G. Mathes, and Jack M. Fletcher. Properties
of Clay's Observation Survey of Early Literacy Achievement: Implications for
early reading intervention research. The
Observation Survey of Early Literacy Achievement (OS; Clay, 1993) is widely
used by Reading Recovery (RR) teachers and others to identify students at-risk
for reading difficulties, plan instruction, and evaluate program effectiveness.
This paper highlights characteristics of the assessment that may limit the
tool's validity and reliability. We proceed with a comprehensive demonstration
of the validity and reliability of the OS subtests in the context of a
randomized and controlled early reading intervention study that included a
small-group intervention with many elements in common with RR.
Nell K. Duke (Michigan
State University), Joseph Martineau, Kenneth Frank, and V. Susan
Bennett-Armistead. The impact of
diversifying genres in first and second grade literacy instruction. This paper reports the results of a two-year
experimental study of the impact of diversifying genres children read, write,
and listen to in early schooling. Ten classes were followed through first and
second grade as their teachers worked toward a balance of narrative,
informational, and other texts; twenty additional classes provided hawthorne
and traditional controls. Children's overall and genre-specific reading and
writing achievement and motivation was measured up to six times. Results
indicate whether the current dominance of narrative text in the early grades is
well-justified, or whether children would benefit from experience with a more
diverse array of genres.
Linnea C. Ehri (Graduate
Center of the City University of New York), Julie Rosenthal, and Marcy Zipke. Contribution of alphabetic enrichment to the
repeated reading of text for struggling readers. Two
treatment groups of 3rd-4th grade struggling readers were given practice
rereading texts to accuracy and fluency criteria. One treatment group received
alphabaetic enrichment instruction as well. This included remediating
children's graphophonemic knowledge and teaching them to fully analyze
graphosyllabic connections to read harder words in the texts. Children (N=30)
were tutored for 28 sessions. A no-treatment control group (N=15) was included.
Preliminary analyses of findings revealed that the alphabetic treatment may
have benefited text reading fluency. More complete analyses as well as
preliminary findings from a second study will be presented.Fataneh Farnia (University of Toronto), Gloria
Ramirez, and Esther Geva. The relation
between oral language proficiency and reading comprehension in ESL children. This study investigated the relationship between Oral
language Proficiency ( OLP) and reading comprehension of a sample of 86
children; 58 ESL and 28 native speakers of English. OLP was measured with
receptive vacabulary (PPVT), expressive vocabulary (EOWPT), and grammatical
awareness. Reading comprehension in Grade 1 was assessed with a series of
narratives. Reading comprehension in grade 4 was assessed with Gate MacGinitie.
Data were analyzed using correlation and multiple regression. OLP contributed
to reading comprehension of both L1 and ESL children in Grade 1, however, the
correlation was highly significant for the ESL group. OLP assessed in Grade 1
predicted reading comprehension of both language groups in Grade 4. Results
also indicated differences in the contribution of OLP indices in reading
comprehension of the two language groups in Grade 4.
Lee Farrington-Flint (Open University), Clare Wood, Dorothy Faulkner, and Katherine Canobi. Identifying patterns of analogical
development in children's early reading. Although
there is substantial evidence that young children can use orthographic
analogies during early reading development, there is general disagreement
regarding the skills often associated with their successful use. It is
necessary to identify those factors critical to governing the successful use of
orthographic analogies in early reading. This paper will report results from an
ongoing study that set out to investigate whether various forms of analogical
problem solving are an important prerequisite for orthographic analogy use in
early reading. A sample of 60, five to six year old beginning readers will be
assessed on various measures of phonological awareness, vocabulary, analogical
reasoning ability and orthographic analogy use. Firstly, the study will examine
whether children’s performance on the various analogy tasks can account for
some of the variance attributed to orthographic analogy use in reading.
Secondly, a cluster analysis will be used to identify whether distinct patterns
of analogical problem solving ability based on the speed and accuracy of children’s
individual responses emerge. These findings may have important implications for
cognitive developmental theory of reading development.
Lauren Figueredo
(University of Alberta), and Connie Varnhagen. Spelling and punctuation checkers don't hurt and can help. We investigated whether the presence of spelling and
punctuation checkers affected the order in which students revised text for
content and surface features. Participants were asked to revise two essays on a
computer, one with the aid of spelling and punctuation checkers, and the other
with the aid of a dictionary. While the checkers helped the participants to
revise text for spelling and punctuation, they did not affect students’ overall
revision processes. Our results are consistent with the view that checkers are
effective in helping to detect and correct errors in text, yet do not inhibit
or distract students from their revision goals.
Alexis Filippini
(University of California, Santa Barbara), Judith English, and Michael C.
Gerber. A linguistic analysis of phoneme
awareness task items across languages: Language specificity and item complexity
for Spanish and English exemplars. Results
of a linguistic analysis of onset, rime and segmentation task items for task
comparability are examined for assessments used in a three year study of cross
language transfer of phonological and word reading skills (Project La Patera).
Differences examined for each of the tests included place and manner of articulation of the initial phoneme(s), number
of phonemes per item, syllabic differences and phonological context of the
initial phoneme(s) for both the English and Spanish test items. The analyses
compares these findings across the two tests administered to first graders in
the beginning of Years Two and Three. Student performance on items is examined
relative to auditory (speech) and orthographic characteristics such as
syllables, rime and onset, and individual phonemes.. Data on task item
differences and student performance are discussed relative to word length, coda
interference, place confusion and other linguistic markers.
Jørgen Frost (). Phonemic awareness, spontaneous writing, and
reading and spelling development from a preventive perspective. The study showed remarkable differences between two
groups with high (HPA) versus low (LPA) phonemic awareness on entry into grade
1. Level of invented spelling at Time 1 was highly predictive of both reading
and spelling ability at the end of grades 1 and 2, but only for the HPA group.
With Time of Mastery regarding phonemic spelling as the independent variable
and reading and spelling at the end of grade 2 as the dependent variable,
regressions analysis indicated strong direct effects of early phonemic spelling
upon later reading and spelling development, but only for the LPA children. The
two groups showed different patterns of development in learning to read and
spell during grades 1 and 2.
Michael M. Gerber
(University of California, Santa Barbara), Judith English, Cara Richards, and
Tisa Jimenez. Cross-language effects of
intensive phonological intervention for Spanish-speaking kindergarteners at
risk for reading failure in English: A longitudinal investigation of early
reading outcomes. Results of
early reading performance culminating from a three year longitudinal interventive
study of relationships among English and Spanish measures of phonological
processing for approximately 370 second grade EL students are presented,
following up a preliminary analysis presented to SSSR in June, 2002. Year Two
results (June 2002) suggested that development of phonological abilities is
independent of characteristics of students' first (L1) language: Spanish
phonological performance was observed to predict ability to perform similarly
on parallel English tasks independent of English expressive proficiency. The
present paper will relate findings to Year Three post-intervention measures,
including English word decoding and early reading outcomes for varying levels
of reading risk among ELs.
Esther Geva (University
of Toronto), and Zohreh Yagoubzadeh. What
are the roles of cognitive processes and language proficiency in the
development of reading fluency in ESL children? The
research examined the extent to which (a) ESL and English-as-a-first-language
(EL1) children resemble on various aspects of reading fluency, and (b) whether
individual differences in reading fluency in ESL and EL1 children can be
understood in terms of similar underlying component process. The overall sample
consisted of 183 Grade-2, ESL children, and 70 native speakers of English as a
first language children (hereafter, EL1). There were significant differences
between the EL1 and ESL children on indices of oral language proficiency
(vocabulary and syntactic awareness). In spite of an oral language proficiency
advantage in the EL1 group, children in the EL1 group did not do better than
the ESL children on any of the cognitive and reading measures. Hierarchical
multiple regression analyses revealed that the most robust predictors of
reading fluency (accuracy+speed Z scores) of simple narratives in both language
groups were rapid automatized naming (RAN) and phonological awareness (PA). 40%
of the variance in the ESL group and 33% of the variance in the EL1 group was
explained by these two variables. Vocabulary, entered first, contributed 10% to
the explained variance in reading fluency in the ESL group, but was not
significant in the EL1 group. Additional analysis focussed on clusters of poor
and good readers, defined in terms of performance on RAN and PA: High RAN+ High
PA, low RAN+ High PA, and Low RAN+ Low PA and (i.e., "double
deficit"). In both language groups children with good PA and fast RAN
outperformed children in the other two subgroups on all the accuracy indices
(e.g., word recognition, pseudoword reading), as well as on word and text
fluency indices. Furthermore, children with good PA but slow RAN outperformed
children in the "double deficit" group. Implications for reading
fluency, L2 reading theory, future research directions and educational practices
will be discussed.
Karen Ghelani (University
of Toronto), and Rosemary Tannock. Beyond
the phonological core and naming deficits: Other relevant processes at work. We investigated whether students with ADHD have
reading difficulties in the absence of comorbid developmental reading
disabilities (RD). We examined cognitive processing and reading abilities in
adolescents with ADHD and RD. The RD group was impaired on all reading tasks
and rapid alphanumeric tasks. The ADHD group was impaired on a rapid sight word
reading task but not on alphanumeric tasks. Both groups were impaired on a
visual span task. Inattention and spatial span measures were significantly
associated with rapid sight word reading. Findings indicate the need to explore
other contributing factors, such as visual processing and attention, in
reading.
Margie Gillis (Haskins
Laboratories), Anne E. Fowler, Susan A. Brady, Laura C. Palumbo, Joan B. Baron,
Tara Smith, and Leonard Katz. Building
the bridge from research to practice: Teachers and students benefit from
ongoing onsite support of reading instruction by research-trained mentors. The Haskins Early Reading Success team seeks to
improve reading instruction by K-3 teachers by offering ongoing onsite support
from carefully selected external Fellows and site-based Teacher Specialists. In
turn, these mentors receive extensive training in research and ongoing guidance
by Haskins research scientists. Examination of students' scores after two years
of school participation indicate significant improvement in spelling, word
recognition and reading of connected text, when compared to scores of students
after only one year of participation. Gains are most dramatic for students who
began the project in kindergarten, indicating that early intervention is particularly
effective.
Rebecca Godfrey (University
of Auckland), and C. Fletcher-Flinn. Fairness
for all: A computerised measure of phonemic sensitivity. A computer-driven discrimination task, testing for the
identification of voiced/voiceless (phonemic) and pre-voiced/voiced
(non-phonemic) contrasts was developed as a measure of phonemic awareness for
young children. Comprehensive reading-related assessments were conducted for
180 children aged 4 to 8 years attending New Zealand kindergartens or schools
varying in the amount of pre-reading/reading instruction and also in
instructional method along the whole-language/phonics continuum. Results were
analysed as a function of each sub-skill from the assessment battery and most
correlated significantly with the discrimination task. Comparisons were made
across instructional methodologies. Speech-contrast discrimination across age
varied significantly and will be compared with theories on the development of
speech perception.
Vincent Goetry (Queen's
University), Philippe Mousty, and Régine Kolinsky. The relationship of stress processing abilities to lexical and reading
development in bilingual children schooled in their second language. In the last decades, second language acquisition
through "immersion" has gained widespread acceptance, first in Canada
and since then in Belgium. The results of extensive, systematic evaluations of
immersion programs in a number of Canadian settings have provided strong
evidence that immersion programs are remarkably effective. However, these
evaluations of immersion programs have mainly concerned English-speaking
children attending a French immersion program. Therefore we will try to find
out if this results can be applied to immersion programs organised in Belgium.
Moreover, few of these previous studies have focused on the fundamental
cognitive processes characterising literacy acquisition in a second language.
Our study focuses on these processes.
Robert F. Goldberg
(University of Pittsburgh), Charles A. Perfetti, and Walter Schneider. Representation of word meaning: Behavioral
and neuroimaging evidence. This poster
addresses how the brain represents the meaning of words to allow for both
metaphoric flexibility and scientific precision. Using behavioral and fMRI
methods, our research investigates how abstract and variable semantic
knowledge, like the category 'living thing', is organized and processed. The
behavioral results show that feature representations learned early in childhood
remain embedded within the semantic system. The neuroimaging results suggest
that those items that cause behavioral difficulty are activated differentially
from items that belong to the same semantic category. These results support the
notion that word meaning relies on a distributed but selective feature-based
cortical network.
Alexandra Gottardo
(Wilfrid Laurier University), Penny Chiappe, Linda S. Siegel, and Adéle
Lafrance. A comparison of phoneme
categorization performance in ESL and native English-speaking adults. The performance of 28 adult English as Second Language
learners was compared to 28 native English-speaking adults (EL1). The
participants were recruited from a clinic sample. The groups were matched on
reading measures. They showed no group differences on measures of reading,
achievement, aptitude or phonological awareness. The EL1 group had a
significantly steeper identification function on the phoneme categorization
task than the ESL group, indicating that the ESL group did not have as well
defined category boundaries for common English phonemes. These findings point
to differences in the categorization of phonemes between ESL and EL1 adults
despite identical reading performance.
Elena L. Grigorenko
(Yale University), Christina Romano, Matthew Jukes, and Damaris Ngorosho. Genetic studies of reading difficulties in
Kiswahili-speaking children. The study
utilizes two different nonoverlapping subsamples of a large cohort of Tanzanian
primary-school students screened with reading achievement tests. The first
subsample included sibpairs, ascertained through a sibling with a reading
problem. The second subsample was a case-control sample. The sibling pairs were
evaluated with a battery aimed at reading-related processes . Only educational
measurements were used in the case-control sample. The sample of sibling pairs
was subjected to a linkage analyses with sets of markers on chromosomes 2, 6,
15, and 18. The linkage analyses resulted in positive signals that were
reevaluated in the case-control subsample.
Yan Gu (Wilfrid
Laurier University), Alexandra Gottardo, Bernice Yan, and Linda S. Siegel. Examining the relationships among spelling,
reading, phonological and orthograhic processing measures in Chinese ESL
children. Spelling,
reading, phonological and orthographic performance was measured in 48 Chinese ESL
children. Relationships between second language (L2) spelling and potential
factors related to spelling were examined. Correlational analyses showed that
L2 but not L1 reading performance was significantly related to L2 spelling
performance. Phonological and orthographic processing in each language were
correlated significantly with L2 spelling. Regression analyses revealed that 1)
phonological measures in both L1 and L2 accounted for variance in L2 spelling
and 2) orthographic measures in L2 but not L1 contributed to L2 spelling. These
results increase our understanding of the interaction between universal and
specific processes of reading and writing acquisition.
Bente E. Hagtvet
(University of Oslo), Erna Horn, and Solveig A. H. Lyster. Connections between spoken and written language: Early precursors of
written problems. Problems in
learning to read and spell are typically associated with a low sensitivity to
the phonological structure of language. The present study includes a broader
language perspective. We investigated the relationships between phonological,
syntactic and semantic skills at ages two through six and later reading and
spelling skills. A sample of 70 Norwegian speaking children of dyslexic parents
participated in the study. They were followed longitudinally from age two
through age nine. The results underscore the predictive power of semantic and
syntactic variables, in addition to phonological factors. Findings are
interpreted with reference to a developmental model involving the whole
language system, and with due respect to the unique contributions made by
different oral language skills at each developmental stage.
Julie Hansen (Queensland
University of Technology), and Judith A. Bowey. Is there a naming speed deficit in developmental reading disability? A
reading-level comparison test of the double-deficit hypothesis. Two 3-group reading-level studies tested the
prediction of the double-deficit hypothesis that poor readers have deficits in
symbol naming speed in comparison to reading-level matched controls. In both
studies, poor fourth-grade readers performed below the level of CA and RL
controls on nonword reading and phonological awareness, but at the same level
as RL controls on naming speed. Measures of word-reading latency, assessed in
Study 2, revealed that poor readers had shorter reading latencies than RL
controls. The double-deficit hypothesis was not supported. No deficit in symbol
naming speed was found among poor readers in comparison to younger
normally-developing readers.
Nicole Harlaar (Institute
of Psychiatry), and Robert Plomin. Associations
between non-verbal, language and reading abilities: A behavioral genetic
perspective. The
aetiology of associations between non-verbal ability, language, phonological
decoding, and sight-word reading was explored in a population sample of 2,655
pairs of 7-year-old twins. Non-verbal ability correlated weakly with the
language, phonological decoding, and reading measures, both phenotypically and
at an aetiological level. Associations between language and the phonological
and reading measures were modest and primarily mediated genetically. A separate
genetic influence was identified that acted on phonological decoding and
sight-word reading, which were substantially correlated phenotypically. These
skills also showed highly similar aetiological profiles. Implications for
molecular genetic studies are discussed.Laura Boynton Hauerwas (Providence College), and Joanne
Walker. Spelling of inflected verbs in
early elementary students. Evidence suggests
that, as spelling develops, children are influenced by their phonological,
morphological and orthographic abilities. Our studied examined early elementary
students’ ability to integrate phonological, morphological and orthographic
information when spelling inflected verbs. To address this, participants were
given a series of spelling and metalinguistic awareness tasks. Results
suggested that the students’ ability to include the inflected endings as well
as represent them phonologically, morphologically and orthographically in their
spelling improved across the first three grades. Their spelling development of
inflected verbs was related to an increase in linguistic and orthographic
awareness skills.
Steven Alan Hecht
(Florida Atlantic University). Emergent
literacy skills and training time uniquely predict variability in responses to
phonemic awareness training in disadvantaged Kindergartners. Factors predicting variability in responses to
phonemic awareness training were investigated with two samples of economically
disadvantaged kindergartners. Effect sizes for post-test phonemic awareness
were comparable between samples. Pretest assessments included phonemic
awareness, letter knowledge, reading, invented spelling, verbal ability, and
print concepts. Invented spelling skills emerged as the best consistent
predictor of emerging phonemic awareness. Relations between phonemic awareness
and spelling are bi-directional. Interestingly, fidelity of treatment
intervention contributed uniquely to variability in post-test levels of
phonemic awareness and spelling, providing important evidence that children can
benefit from greater amounts of phonemic awareness instruction independently of
their initial abilities.
Connie Suk-Han Ho
(University of Hong Kong), David WAI-Ock Chan, Agnes Au, Suk-Man Tsang, Suk-Han
Lee. Reading-related cognitive deficits
in developmental dyslexia, ADHD, DCD, and borderline intelligence among Chinese
children. The present
study examined reading-related cognitive deficits on 108 Chinese children. These
children were grouped according to their learning disabilities, namely
developmental dyslexia (DYS), attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD),
developmental coordination disorder (DCD), or borderline intelligence (BI). They
were tested on literacy, rapid naming, phonological, orthographic, and visual
processing. It was found that (a) the ADHD and DCD groups performed similarly,
but better than the DYS and BI groups in most of the tasks; (b) the DYS group
performed better than the BI group in most cognitive measures, except rapid
naming and literacy; and (c) the DYS group was the poorest in literacy and
rapid naming. The authors conclude that rapid naming deficit is the marker
deficit for Chinese developmental dyslexia.
Angelia Holcomb (Texas
A&M University), Regina-Boulware Gooden, Emily Ocker, and R. M. Joshi. Decoding, comprehension, and fluency:
Developmental changes. In the 1991
report by the National Research Council a fluent reader will have adequate
skills in decoding, comprehension, and fluency. This finding was empirically
supported by the componential model of reading which is an extension of Gough’s
simple view of reading. The componential model of reading hypothesizes that
reading equals decoding multiplied by comprehension plus fluency. This model
was applied to Chall’s developmental thought that children learn to read in
first through third and then read to learn fourth and above.
Sherri L. Horner
(Bowling Green State University). Young
children's knowledge about reading, environmental print, and words. This study investigated the relationship between young
children’s knowledge of environmental print and word reading. There are two alternative
perspectives on the role of environmental print in learning to read. Therefore,
the researcher used methodology and reading outcomes that have been used by
proponents of both perspectives to compare these alternative theories. One
hundred and thirty-three preschool through second graders were assessed on
alphabet naming, primer word reading, and five researcher-developed
environmental print tasks. Results showed that the vast majority of children
attempted to make meaning in the more contextualized measures but only those
children who could read primer words could also read the decontextualized
environmental print words.
Michelle K. Hosp
(University of Utah), and Lynn S. Fuchs. The
relation between oral reading fluency and decoding, word reading, and
comprehension across grades 1 through 4. The
purpose of this study was to examine the relation between oral reading fluency
as defined by rate and accuracy with criterion measures of decoding, word
reading, and comprehension across grades 1 through 4. While oral reading
fluency encompasses decoding, word reading, and comprehension, this study provides
evidence that the relation is not equally strong across these areas, nor is it
similar across grades. With the increasing emphasis on oral reading fluency it
is important to determine what reading skills are more closely related to oral
reading fluency and how this relation changes across grades.
Roxanne F. Hudson
(Washington State University), and Holly B. Lane. Reading-writing connections: Compositional fluency of developing
writers under various priming conditions. This
study addressed two questions related to the effects of priming conditions on
the writing of second graders (n = 195): What are the effects of priming
conditions on the whole group? and Would these effects be found among smaller
subgroups based on measures related to compositional fluency? Students wrote
six narratives in response to story starters presented in different ways
(copying, dictation, discussion, discussion-copying, discussion-dictation, and
topic). Data were collected on measures related to compositional fluency. An ANOVA
with repeated measures showed that priming condition and writing occasion were
significant effects. Theoretical implications and implications for classroom
practice are discussed.
Jacqui Hulslander
(University of Colorado, Boulder), and Richard Olson. The identification and utilization of nonword repetition items which
maximally discriminate good and poor readers. Analyses
of an 80-item test of nonword repetition reveal that several linguistic
characteristics, including number of syllables and number of phonemes, predict
which items will best discriminate between good and poor readers. Items’
overall accuracy and ability to discriminate groups are largely independent
(r=.27). The more discriminating an item the higher its correlation to
vocabulary, digit span, and phonological awareness (r=.82 for each). The
results suggest that fewer, more discriminating items may produce am ore direct
test of underlying phonological representations related to reading.
Accordingly, results using the full 80-item test and a maximally discriminating
20-item version are compared for several phenotypic and genetic analyses.
Nancy Ewald Jackson
(University of Iowa). Do university
students' reading skills matter? Reading
skills of 193 university sophomores and juniors were examined with tests of
component skills and text comprehension, including ACT Reading Composite
scores. Three orthogonal principal components described the reading scores:
Word Recoding Accuracy, Reading Speed, and Text Comprehension Accuracy. Only
Text Comprehension Accuracy was at all related to grade-point average (GPA; r =
.15). Cluster analysis, using a broader set of measures that included
self-reports of reading and spelling ability and tests of phoneme awareness and
spelling, identified four distinct groups of students: Good Readers, Typical
Readers, Struggling Readers, and Hasty Readers. These groups were similar in
mean GPA.
Debra Jared (University
of Western Ontario), Pierre Cormier, and Betty Ann Levy. Early reading development in French immersion. Many Canadian parents would like their children to be
able to speak and read in both official languages of the country. Consequently,
early French Immersion is a popular educational placement for anglophone
children in Canada. In French Immersion programs, children begin formal
schooling, including learning to read, in a second language that is often a
minority language in their environment and a language that their parents
typically do not speak well. We report the first year of a longitudinal
investigation of the reading development of 222 anglophone children enrolled in
French Immersion programs. Children from four different Canadian cities in
Ontario and New Brunswick were tested in Kindergarten and again in Grade 1. The
amount of French instruction in Kindergarten varied across the sites from 100%
of the day to 0%, and in Grade 1 from 100% to 50% of the day. An important
issue addressed in our study concerns the relationship between Kindergarten
oral language skills and reading ability in Grade One. We investigated whether
children who have better vocabulary and syntactic knowledge in their first
language in Kindergarten were more likely to successfully learn to read in
their second language and whether children who acquire more oral French in
Kindergarten were more likely to be successful readers of French in Grade 1. We
also examined whether home variables such as parents' ability to speak French
and the child's exposure to French in the home was related to French reading
ability. Furthermore, we investigated whether the same or different levels of
phonological awareness (syllable, onset-rime, phoneme) in Kindergarten
predicted success at reading in French and in English in Grade 1.
Tim Johnston (Queen's
University), and John R. Kirby. Does
naming speed complicate the simple view of reading? The Simple View of reading (Gough & Tunmer, 1986)
proposes that the product of decoding and listening comprehension equals
reading. Joshi and Aaron (2000) found that a letter naming speed test added
significantly to the simple view in predicting reading comprehension. We
investigated this hypothesis in a larger group of grade 3 children (n = 152),
and added a control for phonological awareness. We found that grade 3 picture
naming speed added significantly to the prediction of grade 3, 4 and 5 reading
comprehension, after controlling for the simple view variate and phonological
awareness. We discuss an up-dated Simple View.
Tami Katzir (Harvard
Graduate School of Education), Beth O'Brien, Robin Morris, Maureen Lovett, and
Maryanne Wolf. Predicting fluent reading
in dyslexic readers: The whole is more than its parts. A primary question of this study involved the ability
of naming speed, orthographic and phonological processing measures, as well as,
word level reading to predict fluent reading. A working
developmental-componential fluency model was proposed in which different
reading levels, processes, and systems function as contributors to reading
fluency. In the present study 160 severely impaired children in second and third
grade were assessed on a variety of fluency measures and reading subskills. The
results demonstrated that a combination of naming speed, phonological,
orthographic, and word reading measures only partially predicted fluent
reading. Implications of these findings for research and practice are
discussed.
Janice M. Keenan
(University of Denver), and Rebecca S. Betjemann. Lexical computations in skilled reading and dyslexia. We assessed the computational architecture of the
mental lexicon in skilled and dyslexic readers (8 years to college-age) using
combinatorial priming in lexical decision. Combinatorial priming assesses
activation from a prime that combines both phonological/graphemic and semantic
relatedness, such as FLOAT for the target BOAT, relative to primes related on
only one dimension, e.g., GOAT or SHIP. All readers showed more priming from
combinatorial primes than single-dimension primes. Combinatorial priming was
clearly additive for skilled readers, but less so for dyslexic readers.
Implications for the functioning of semantic and phonological/graphemic units
in the computational processes of the lexicon are discussed.
Nenagh Kemp (University
of Manchester). Pronunciation-based
spelling differences between British and Australian children and adults. British and Australian adults and 6- to 7-year-old
children spelled 24 words whose final vowel sound is spelled i or e, and
pronounced either /I/ or /schwa/, depending on accent. Participants in both age
groups tended to (mis)spell vowel sounds as they pronounced them; for example British
children often wrote rockit and muffin, whereas Australian children wrote
rocket and muffen. These results support the idea that sound-based spelling is
not restricted to children’s writing, and then superseded by more sophisticated
strategies (Pennington et al., 1987), but is also used by adults when they
encounter difficult words (Treiman & Barry, 2000).
Gary R. Kidd (Indiana
University), Charles S. Watson, Phil J. Connell, David A. Eddins, Mary D.
Gospel, Betty U. Watson, Douglas H. Horner, David A. Goss, Andrya Lowther, Bill
B. Rainey, and Glenn Krueger. Linguistic,
cognitive and sensory-perceptual factors in the academic performance of
elementary school children: The Benton-IU Project, grades 1-4. The Benton-IU Project is a multidisciplinary,
epidemiological-longitudinal investigation of predictors of academic
achievement in elementary school. An extensive test battery of
individually-administered standardized cognitive, linguistic, sensory, and
perceptual tests was given to all children entering first grade in the four
elementary schools of Benton County, Indiana, over a three-year period (N=
472). The children were retested in the fourth grade. An earlier report
summarized preliminary findings from the first two grades. This report focuses
on the relation between measures from the first and fourth grade testing, using
path and cross-lagged analyses to assess the causes of reading failure.
John R. Kirby (Queen's
University), Melissa Bell, and Hélène Deacon. Grammatical awareness and the spelling of grammatical morphemes. Nunes, Bryant and Bindman (1997) developed a Sentence
Analogy measure of grammatical awareness related specifically to verb past
tenses, and showed that it was predictive of success in spelling the ed ending
of real verbs. We examined the ability of the Sentence Analogy test,
administered in grades 2, 3, and 4, to predict the spelling of grammatical
morphemes (e.g., -s, -ed, -ing) in pseudoverbs in grade 4. The Sentence Analogy
effect was significant in every grade, and survived separate controls for
intelligence, phonological awareness, phonological memory, naming speed and
spelling ability. The effect was not confined to ed endings.
Trudy Kwong (University
of Alberta), and Connie K. Varnhagen. Hear's
the problem: Long-term effects of auditory processing on spelling ability. Introductory psychology students at University of
Alberta completed linguistic and nonlinguistic auditory tasks, standardized
spelling tests, and retroactive spelling strategy reports. Spelling ability was
correlated with linguistic, but not nonlinguistic, processing. We used a
median-split to divide students into phonological versus nonphonological
spellers. We found that the correlation between linguistic processing and
spelling ability existed only for the phonological spellers; alternate
strategies allowed spellers to circumvent less accurate processing.
Furthermore, no correlation was found between linguistic processing and use of
phonology, suggesting that instruction may be beneficial in helping spellers
choose strategies adaptively. A child comparison study is currently underway.Adele Lafrance (Wilfrid Laurier University), and
Alexandra Gottardo. English reading
development in French-speaking children.
Forty-two children with French as their first language (L1) were tested in
Senior Kindergarten. Measures of reading and phonological processing were
administered in English and French. The strongest predictors of English word
reading were French word reading and French phonological awareness. The
strongest predictors of French word reading were English word reading and
French phonological awareness. This finding demonstrates that a relationship
exists between L1 phonological awareness and reading in both L1 and L2; word
decoding ability transferred across languages. Similar analyses will be
conducted on Grade 1 data that is currently being collected from the same
children.
Karin Landerl (University
of Salzburg), and Pieter Reitsma. Orthographic
memory and memory for number facts. Many
dyslexic children show problems in arithmetic skills too. However, the
connection between these two learning disabilities is not very well understood.
One explanation might be that the build up of orthographic memory and memory
for numerical facts is based on similar mechanisms. To examine the association
between these two types of knowledge acquisition, a word learning and a number
fact learning task (repeated presentation of words and simple additions) were
carried out with children at the beginning of 2nd grade with relatively poor
math and reading skills. The learning curves on accuracy and response times for
trained for word spellings and number facts will be compared and will
demonstrate whether processes of storage in both domains are related.
Nicole Landi (University
of Pittsburgh), and Charles A. Perfetti. A
time course for lexical activation in skilled and less skilled readers. Behavioral studies of word identification, utilizing
priming and masking paradigms and eye tracking have shown that both
orthographic and phonological information is available to readers early on in
word processing — usually before
semantic information (Perfetti & Bell, 1991: Lukatella & Turvey, 1994,
Lee, Rayner & Pollatsek, 1999). The current study uses behavioral and eye
tracking methods to investigate the time course for the availability of
orthographic, phonological and semantic information across reading skill levels
of adult college students. The study focuses on comparing orthographic and
phonological form priming as well as semantic priming for skilled and less
skilled readers.
Holly B. Lane (University
of Florida), Martha B. League, Stephanie Al Otaiba, Joseph Torgesen, and Paige
C. Pullen. Leave no teacher behind: Using
structured tutoring experiences to prepare teachers to apply scientifically
based reading research. Tutoring
for struggling beginning readers is becoming a common approach to intervention.
In some popular tutoring programs, the role of tutor preparation is emphasized.
This study compared Reading Recovery with another tutoring model that uses
similar materials and methods but requires substantially less tutor
preparation. The purpose of the study was to determine differences in the
effects of the two models on student achievement for struggling beginning
readers. The student outcomes on several measures of reading achievement were
not significantly different in the two models.
Alba B. Langenthal
(Graduate Center of the City University of New York), Linnea C. Ehri, and Carla
Langenthal. How do novice and experienced
first-grade teachers evaluate reading ability in their students? This study examined ten experienced and ten novice
first-grade teachers' knowledge of the development of reading skills in
beginners. The independent variables were (1) experience teaching beginning
reading and (2) amount of training in reading instruction and the structure of
language. Dependent variables included working knowledge, assessment practices,
content knowledge, teaching efficacy, and theoretical orientation to reading.
Results showed group differences in teachers' references to non-academic
factors affecting their students' reading progress. Significant relationships
were observed among teachers' training, their content knowledge, and their
assessment practices. Results suggest that teacher training positively
influences teachers' knowledge and assessment practices.
Mark Lauterbach (Graduate
Center of the City University of New York), and Michael Evans. Spelling development in early elementary
students and the contribution of classroom factors. This study investigates growth of student spelling
development in kindergarten through second grade, and explores the contribution
of teacher and instructional factors to this process. Students from seven
inner-city parochial schools will be given developmentally structured spelling
tests at 4 times over the school year. The teachers will be assessed on 4 main
factors: teaching experience and training, knowledge of the reading and
spelling processes, instructional practices, and time spent on instruction. A
3-level hierarchical linear model repeated measures design will be used to
model the individual subject’s growth and explore the contributions of
individual and classroom level variables.
T. V. Joe Layng (Headsprout,
Inc.), Janet S. Twyman, and M. A. Stikeleather. Headsprout Reading: The research base. For
a beginning reading program to be successful, the National Reading Panel
(2000), among others, has identified critical program constituents scientific
investigation has determined as essential. Headsprout, a privately-funded
company, has taken the approach that teaching skills and strategies critical to
successful reading requires the same commitment to a scientific approach, as
does the scientific study of reading itself. Headsprout Reading is the result
of the marriage of reading science with learning science. This presentation
provides a detailed description of the single-subject control analysis
methodology employed in the over two-year effort to scientifically design and
test Headsprout Reading, a fully learner verified, Internet-based, beginning
reading program for young learners.
Martha B. League
(University of Florida), Holly B. Lane, Paige C. Pullen, and Tabatha Scharlach.
Tutoring struggling beginning readers: A
comparison of tutoring models and tutor preparation. Tutoring for struggling beginning readers is becoming
a common approach to intervention. In some popular tutoring programs, the role
of tutor preparation is emphasized. This study compared Reading Recovery with
another tutoring model that uses similar materials and methods but requires
substantially less tutor preparation. The purpose of the study was to determine
differences in the effects of the two models on student achievement for
struggling beginning readers. The student outcomes on several measures of
reading achievement were not significantly different in the two models.
Katia Lecocq (Laboratoire
de Psychologie Expérimentale), Philippe Mousty, Régine Kolinsky, Vincent
Goetry, José Morais, and Jesus Alegria. Longitudinal
study of metaphonological development and of reading and spelling processes in
children attending an immersion program. In
the last decades, second language acquisition through "immersion" has
gained widespread acceptance, first in Canada and since then in Belgium. The
results of extensive, systematic evaluations of immersion programs in a number
of Canadian settings have provided strong evidence that immersion programs are
remarkably effective. However, these evaluations of immersion programs have
mainly concerned English-speaking children attending a French immersion
program. Therefore we will try to find out if this results can be applied to
immersion programs organised in Belgium. Moreover, few of these previous
studies have focused on the fundamental cognitive processes characterising
literacy acquisition in a second language. Our study focuses on these
processes.
Annukka Lehtonen
(University of Oxford), and Peter Bryant. The
relationship between phoneme and morphological awareness and children's
spelling in Finnish: A longitudinal study. Earlier
studies in regular orthographies have concentrated on investigating how either
phonemic awareness or morphological awareness affects spelling. Our study aimed
to answer two questions: How do these metalinguistic skills affect spelling
development across time, and is there a reciprocal relationship between
spelling and metalinguistic awareness in Finnish? Children did phoneme Oddity
and Tapping tasks, a pseudo-word inflection task and a spelling task in
December and April of Year 1 and December of Year 2. Both phoneme and
morphological awareness were significant and independent predictors of spelling
a year later, and spelling also predicted the development of later
metalinguistic skills.
Che Kan Leong (University
of Saskatchewan), Pui Wan Cheng, and Li Hai Tan. Orthographic and phonological sensitivity both important in learning to
read and spell English as L2. It was
hypothesized that sensitivity to both orthographic and phonologic structure of
English is important for Chinese children learning to read and spell English as
a second language (L2). From a battery of 13 group and individual orthographic
and phonologic tasks given to 156 grades 4, 5 and 6 Chinese children in Hong
Kong six experimental tasks from hierarchical multiple regression analyses
explained 76% and 70% respective of English reading and spelling. Linear
structural equation modeling (LISREL 8.51) shows the model with the two
separate though related latent constructs of orthographic and phonologic
sensitivity to provide the best fit for "literacy."
Nonie K. Lesaux (University
of British Columbia), and Linda Siegel. The
development of reading in children from diverse backgrounds: A longitudinal
latent growth curve analysis. The
prevalence of reading failure is higher in low-income populations, and in
individuals with English as a second language (ESL). The participants of the
5-year longitudinal study are all of the children who entered kindergarten a
school district. In kindergarten, all children identified as at-risk for
reading failure received intervention to augment their pre-reading and language
skills. The development of reading of the participants from kindergarten to
grade 4 was examined using individual growth curves. The results show that it
is possible to mediate the negative effects of socioeconomic status and ESL
status through early intervention for at-risk children.
Valerie Marciarille LeVasseur (University of Connecticut), Paul Macaruso, Laura Conway
Palumbo, and Donald Shankweiler. Cuing
linguistic structure promotes fluent reading: A confirmation. Is fluency in reading facilitated by marking major
syntactic boundaries in text? Third graders read aloud passages of varying
difficulty under two text format conditions: In one condition, ends of lines
coincided with ends of clauses; in the other, line breaks always interrupted a
major constituent. The results show that text formats that avoid interrupting
phrasal units result in fewer false starts at the beginning of lines following
a return sweep. The findings confirm and extend our earlier results, indicating
a benefit of phrasal cuing in promoting fluent reading, especially for weaker
readers.
Iris Levin (Tel
Aviv University), and Dorit Aram. Children
and mothers use children's names as source of letters: Sociocultural
perspective. Kindergartners
use letters from their names in spelling (Treiman & Kessler). We analyzed
this phenomenon from a socio-cultural perspective. The use of own name letters
was shown to be prevalent among low SES, and absent among middle-high SES
kindergartners; Low SES mothers were sensitive to their children’s greater
familiarity with their written name and used it in joint-writing. The
difference between social groups was interpreted as a function of children’s
level of writing, as the phenomenon is typical for children who are unaware of
the alphabetic principle. Mothers’ sensitivity allows them to act within the
child’s ZPD in mediating writing.
Betty Ann Levy (McMaster
University), Zhiyu Gong, Mary Ann Evans, and Debra Jared. Emergence of orthography. Young
children's understanding of the conventions of print and spelling develops
rapidly from preschool to early school years. 450 children, aged 4 to 7 years,
performed 2-alternative forced choice tasks that required them to discriminate
acceptable from unacceptable printed forms. The unacceptable print varied
across 13 dimensions, from graphic violations (scribbles, pictures, alignments
etc.) to abstract understanding of English spelling. The 13 dimensions separate
into 3 more general groupings of knowledge about print and spelling that showed
different growth curves. Home literacy information was used to determine how
early literacy experience relates to the child's knowledge about print and
spelling.
Orly Lipka (University
of British Columbia), and Linda S. Siegel. How
do native language skills impact the reading and spelling in English as a
second language. This
longitudinal study examined reading and spelling development of 100 ESL
children from seven language families in kindergarten and grade 3. Reading,
spelling, phonological processing, syntax, lexical access and memory skills
were assessed in kindergarten. Additional tasks were incorporated into the
battery to assess cognitive and reading processes in grade 3. Results indicated
negative and positive transfer from the first language to the second. Students
from different language groups performed differently on the reading and
spelling tasks, based on first language skills. The presentation discusses unique
characteristics of different languages and their impact on learning English as
a second language.
Deborah G. Litt (University
of Maryland). The incidence and influence
of phonological awareness and naming speed deficits among children learning to
read in Reading Recovery. Fifty-nine
children who entered Reading Recovery in Fall, 2001 were tested on phonological
awareness and rapid object naming pre and posttreatment. Students were
classified along the dimensions proposed under the double-deficit hypothesis. A
high incidence of phonological awareness and naming speed deficits were found
pretreatmentclose to half were double-deficit; only 1 child was no deficit. Skill
in both areas improved during Reading Recovery instruction —20.4% were
no-deficit posttreatment. Stronger reading outcomes were associated with
overcoming deficits.
Ying Liu (University
of Pittsburgh), Charles Perfetti, and Min Wang. Priming and interference in reading Chinese by English readers. American colleges students enrolled in a Chinese
language course participated in a year-long learning study. Two experiments
were reported in current presentation: a primed naming experiment and a
pronunciation and meaning judgment experiment. Results from the primed naming
experiment showed priming effect for graphically similar and homophone
character pairs. More interesting, homophone interference occurred when
subjects made judgments of meaning similarity, suggesting that with enough
learning, L2 readers, like native speakers, activate phonology when reading for
meaning. It appears that 4-6 months of classroom learning is necessary to
observe the automatic activation of phonology.Paul Macaruso (Community College of Rhode Island),
and Donald Shankweiler. Relationship
between spelling success and reading exposure. There is much debate in the literature regarding the
extent to which spelling success is affected by reading exposure. Adults
spelled a set of "difficult to spell" words (e.g., champagne) on
three occasions, were exposed to the correct spellings on five occasions, and
then spelled the words again on two occasions. Reading exposure lead to
temporary improvement in spelling but performance dropped to baseline after one
week. Improvement was not a function of overall spelling ability. However,
consistency of spelling errors was related to spelling ability. These results
point to the limited degree to which reading exposure impacts spelling success.
Sharon MacCoubrey
(Queen's University), and Lesly Wade-Woolley. Phonemic awareness training of at-risk French immersion kindergarten
students. The present
study examines the effects of two types of French language training programs on
phonological awareness development and word reading in at-risk English
native-speakers enrolled in the French Immersion (FI) kindergarten program.
At-risk students are assigned to training in either: (a) phonemic awareness
(PA), in which the students receive explicit instruction in phoneme analysis
and synthesis; or (b) vocabulary enrichment (VE), in which students receive
lessons focusing on vocabulary building and oral language development. Three
testing sessions (pre- / post-tests) are used to evaluate the effectiveness of
the training. The findings contribute to the development of second language
reading acquisition theories.
Frank Manis (University
of Southern California), Kim A. Lindsey, and Caroline E. Bailey. Four-year longitudinal study of reading
development in English language learners. The
study examined developing relationships among language and reading skills in
220 Spanish-speaking children learning to read English in an early-exit
bilingual program. The children were tested in Spanish in kindergarten and in
English and Spanish in grades 1 to 3 on a battery of theoretically important
predictive and outcome measures. Results showed that letter knowledge and
phonological awareness were the most consistent predictors of later reading
skills within and across languages. RAN tasks accounted for substantial
independent variance in fluency, but not accuracy measures in 3rd grade.
Expressive vocabulary had language-specific predictive relationships to later
reading comprehension.
Vanessa E. G. Martens (University of Amsterdam), and Peter F. de Jong. The use of orthographic knowledge in pseudoword reading by dyslexic and
normal readers. In this
study, we investigated dyslexic children’s use of orthographic knowledge in
pseudoword reading. Dyslexic children, Chronological Age controls, and Reading
Age controls read a set of one-syllable pseudowords composed of high or low
frequent bigrams, in either lower or MiXeD CaSe. Case mixing was assumed to
prevent the use of sublexical orthographic knowledge. All three groups read
high frequent bigram words faster than low frequent ones. Case mixing slowed
down both control groups, but did not affect the dyslexics’ latencies. These
results suggest that dyslexics do have orthographic knowledge at some level,
but do not integrate this knowledge in the same (efficient) way as do both
control groups.
Sandra Martin-Chang
(McMaster University), and Betty Ann Levy. Contextual
facilitation and fluency of transfer: Evidence from good, poor, and average
readers. Two
experiments examined the transfer of reading fluency as measured by the
increase of reading accuracy, speed, and comprehension of novel test passages
following two experimental training programs. Context Training contained target
words that were embedded in children's stories, and List Training presented
words in isolation. Good and Poor readings in Grade 4 and average readers in
Grade 2 were examined. Results indicated that readers of all ability showed
speed benefits on transfer texts from both types of training compared to
control. However, the increases in speed were larger for all readers following
context training compared to list training.
Imola Marton (University
of Toronto), and Esther Geva. Dynamic
approaches to understanding reading efficiency in English monolingual and
bilingual primary level children. Individual
growth curves and regression models are used to analyze the development of
reading efficiency in monolingual (EL1) and English as Second Language (ESL)
children. Growth curve models may provide a more dynamic measure of reading
efficiency than the traditional regression approach, because they are more
sensitive in capturing individual differences in the rate of change over time.
It is hypothesized that efficient readers are characterized by steeper growth
curve trajectories on measures of rapid automatized naming (RAN) and
phonological awareness (PA) than non-efficient readers in both language groups.
Linda H. Mason (University
of Illinois). Two strategies for reading
comprehension: Effects on performance for 5th-grade students who struggle with
obtaining meaning from expository text. The
effectiveness of two expository reading comprehension strategies on oral
reading comprehension performance of 32 fifth-grade students with and without
disabilities who struggled with reading was examined in this experimental group
design study. Students received explicit instruction in either Think Before
Reading, Think While Reading, Think After Reading (TWA) with self-regulated
strategy development or reciprocal questioning (RQ). Analysis of Covariance was
used to analyze results from 5 oral comprehension measures obtained at pretest,
posttest, and maintenance. Results indicated that students in TWA had improved
performance when compared to students in RQ. Medium and large effect sizes were
obtained.
Michael F. McKay
(Australian Catholic University), G. Brian Thompson, and Claire M. Fletcher-Flinn.
A disassociation effect of explicit
phonics instruction on the reading strategies of low progress beginning
readers. This is a
cross-national study of matched samples of low-progress beginning readers, one
receiving explicit phonics instruction, the other not. In text reading, the
children were equal in word accuracy and comprehension. However, the nonphonics
sample was superior in speed of text reading, despite their inferior
phonological recoding, as shown in speed and accuracy of reading pseudowords.
The latter was in part due to their failure to use a 'sounding-out' strategy.
In text reading the incidence of 'no overt response' and of 'sounding out' did
not differ significantly. The higher reading speed probably derived from
greater use of implicit lexical processes.
Adrine McKenzie (University
of Toronto). Primary prevention: Its role
in the academic achievement of immigrant children. The impact of primary prevention initiatives on
children's well-being has not gone unnoticed (Durlak & Wells, 1997). Less
well-developed is the body of literature on the overall adaptation process of
immigrant children (Beiser et. al., 1999), and the role of primary prevention
initiatives on specific populations (Durlak & Wells, 1997), including
ethnically diverse and immigrant children from low-income families. Better Beginnings, Better Futures is a large,
primary prevention, government-funded project that is operating in seven income
twenty-five year project are: to prevent emotional, behavioural, social, physical
and cognitive problems in young children in socio-economically disadvantaged
neighbourhoods, and to promote healthy child development in these children
(Ontario Ministry of Social Services, 1989). Toward these ends supports such as
nutrition programs for children, home visiting, parenting programs, and
classroom enrichment have been implemented in the neighbourhoods. Data on
approximately 1670 families in two cohorts (ages 0-4 and 4-8) aimed at
examining well-being in the aforementioned areas have been collected. The main
purpose of the presentation is to report on one aspect of this large-scale
prevention program, namely, the impact involvement in a primary prevention
initiative has on the academic achievement of immigrant children. Information
from a variety of sources including child measures, teacher reports and parent
interviews was obtained. Intervention, gender and individual differences are
examined over time. The proposed presentation focuses on a target child in 216
families (n= 99 in one intervention site and n= 117 in a matched control site).
These children were followed from ages 4 to 8. Children born to parents who
self- identified as being born outside Canada, and who have been living in
Canada prior to the birth of the child in 1989, were included in the research.
The parents emigrated from various developing regions including India, Jamaica
and Somalia. The control group consists of newcomer children living in
communities not receiving intervention. Data comparable to the intervention group
has been collected from control families. In addition to demographic
information collected, information regarding cognitive ability, attitude
towards reading and academic achievement are examined. Included as a measure of
cognitive development is the block design sub-test of the Wechsler Intelligence
Test for Children-Revised (WISC-R). The Attitude towards Reading Scale was
administered at grades one through three. The children also completed a number
of academic measures including the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test Revised
(PPVT-R), the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised (WRAT-R), the Key Math
Diagnostic Arithmetic Test (KMDAT), and grade three provincial testing scores,
Education Quality and Accountability Office (EQAO) in reading, writing and arithmetic.
At this point, all the data have been scored and some of the analyses
completed. The preliminary results point some important gender and intervention
differences in academic achievement. Using hierarchical linear modeling (HLM),
analyses will be conducted to examine whether differences in oral vocabulary
exist between the control and intervention groups, between boys and girls, and
across individual children over a five-year span. Given the absence of research
on the role of primary prevention on immigrant children the present study aim
to further our understanding of the salient factors that impact on immigrant
children the learning trajectories of individual children over time, it aims to
provide insight into the way newcomer children acquire receptive vocabulary
over a five-year period. This understanding can be instrumental in informing
teaching practice, and correspondingly, student learning.
John McNamara (University
of Saskatchewan), Sheri Simonot, Mary Scissons, and Jody Dahlen. Using measures of phoneme awareness and
letter-sound knowledge to identify at-risk readers in kindergarten. This study measured phonemic awareness and
letter-sound knowledge of 647 Kindergarten students across three school
divisions. The primary purpose was to establish early identification markers
for children at-risk for reading failure. Three measures of phoneme awareness
and three measures of letter-sound knowledge were given to all participants.
All six measures statistically significantly identified those children at-risk
for reading failure. Further, a factor analysis with varimax rotation led to
two separate factors. The first factor was interpreted as letter-sound
knowledge and may identify all children at-risk for reading failure including
those affected by SES, ESL, and environmental disadvantage. The second factor
was interpreted as phoneme awareness and may identify those children at-risk
for reading because of a specific phonological processing problem
characteristic of dyslexia.
Eleni Morfidi (SCO-Kohnstamm
Institute), and Aryan Van der Leij. The
development of phonological and literacy skills of Dutch poor and average
readers who learn English as a second language. The
present study aims to investigate the development of phonological and literacy
skills of average and poor Dutch readers who learn English as a second
language. Two groups of average (n=25) and poor readers (n=25) at secondary
school (year 1 and 2) are followed up after nine months (year 2 and 3
respectively). The two groups are matched for age, gender and listening
comprehension. The first part of the study has already been conducted. The
findings suggested reading difficulties of phonological nature, evident in the
second language. Speed limitations were observed in both languages. In
addition, individual differences indicated that a small subgroup of poor readers with good orthographic skills
had better than expected reading ability in English. The second experiment will
explore the development of reading and subsequent skills in both languages.
Louise Morrison (York
University), and Esther Geva. Comprehension
monitoring in first and second language reading: The role of reading
proficiency and individual differences in lower-level processes. In this paper, I report the results of a cross-lingual
study on the role of comprehension monitoring and underlying
linguistics/cognitive processes on first and second language reading
proficiency (English and French, respectively). Results show that successful
monitoring, as measured by error detection performance at the discourse level,
does transfer across languages, and that monitoring performance is highly
correlated with reading proficiency in both languages. While monitoring
performance in English was the most important predictor of reading proficiency
in both languages, lower level processes such as word recognition and working
memory played an important role in predicting reading proficiency in both
languages.
Jack Mostow (Carnegie
Mellon University), Joseph Beck, Juliet Bey, Fiona Callaghan, Andrew Cuneo,
June Sison, and Brian Tobin. An embedded
experiment to evaluate the effectiveness of vocabulary previews in an automated
reading tutor. When does
taking time to preview a new word before reading a story improve vocabulary and
comprehension more than encountering the word in context? To address this
question, the 2001-2002 version of Project LISTEN's Reading Tutor embedded an
automated experiment to compare three types of vocabulary preview — defining the word, giving a synonym, or
just asking about the word — and a
control condition. Outcomes included within-story comprehension as measured by
performance on multiple-choice cloze questions, and post-story vocabulary as
measured by matching words to their definitions. We analyze results based on
thousands of randomized trials.
Jessica Nelson (University
of Pittsburgh), Michal Balass, and Charles Perfetti. Effects of phonological, orthographic, and semantic training of single
words on reading comprehension: An eye-tracking study. An eye-tracking study was conducted in order to
examine the effects of targeted vocabulary training (either orthographic,
phonological, or semantic) on eye movements during reading. Subjects were
trained on different sets of rare words in each of three training environments:
orthographic/phonological, orthographic/semantic, and phonological/semantic. We
then recorded eye movements during reading for comprehension as subjects read
sentences containing those words. Measures were compared with those taken on
rare words on which they were not trained, and on known words. This experiment
is designed to break down the contribution of orthographic, phonological, and
semantic representations to reading and comprehension.
Trude Nergard Nillsen (University of Oslo), and Bente E. Hagtvet. Reading problems at age 12 in an at-risk sample of children of dyslexic
parents. The study
investigates the frequencies and qualities of reading problems at age 12 in a
sample of Norwegian speaking children with a genetic risk for dyslexia (N=50).
It is an extension of an ongoing longitudinal project focusing connections
between spoken and written language development from age two through age nine
in children of dyslexic parents (N=70) (Hagtvet, Horn, Lassen, Lauvås, Lyster
& Misund, 1998). Different aspects of the reading and spelling skills of
the children were studied on reassessment at age 12. About 50% of these
children had struggled in learning to read and spell, but at age 12 a fair
number of the slow readers appeared to have normalized their reading skills
according to parents’ reports. The reassessment showed great variations in
reading skills, and did not in all cases confirm the parents’ reports. In the
presentation we shall discuss the characteristics of the reading problems of
the youngsters, as related to previous oral and written language performances.
Simone Nunes (Graduate
Center of the City University of New York), and Linnea C. Ehri. Understanding short vowel knowledge in
beginning readers. The
objective of this study was to explore beginners’ knowledge of short vowels and
its relationship to their reading and spelling abilities. Twenty-four five and
six-year-old children completed several tasks assessing knowledge of
letter-sound and sound-letter associations, word and pseudoword reading, and spelling.
Findings suggested that order of acquisition of short vowels reflects the
distinctiveness of articulatory features among the vowels. Children’s mistakes
in short vowel sound production showed use of a letter name strategy. Short
vowel knowledge was significantly correlated with reading and spelling
performance.
Ana Laura Pauchulo
(Wilfrid Laurier University), and Alexandra Gottardo. Understanding reading development in second language learners in Canada
and the USA. Forty
native Spanish speaking Grade 1 children will be tested. This study proposes to
examine the relationship of first language (L1) and second language (L2)
linguistic variables and demographic variables in English as a Second Language
(ESL) learners to their English literacy skills. In particular this study will examine predictors of English word
reading performance using measures of phonological processing and letter
knowledge in English and Spanish. The performance of the participants in the
present study will be compared to results from a similar study in the United
States.
Stephen A. Petrill
(Pennsylvania State University), and Kirby Deater-Deckard. Environmental influences on early reading: Evidence from an adoption
study. Behavioral genetic studies
have suggested that both genetics and environment are important to reading
ability in early childhood. What is less well understood are the
gene-environment processes that operate in reading and related cognitive
skills. The relationship between reading, general cognitive ability, and the
environment was examined using 150 school-age adoptive children and their
families drawn from the Northeast Northwest Collaborative Adoption Projects. Results
suggested that the significant relationships between the post-adoptive
environment and reading are those that involve parental responsiveness and
parents allowing their children to act on an interest in reading as opposed to
more distal measures.
Linda M. Phillips
(University of Alberta), Heather L. Simple, and Dorothy Steffler. Understanding reading development among
Canadian aboriginal children in first grade. Our interest is to better understand the factors that contribute to
the development of reading among Aboriginal children (whose first language may
not be either of our official languages). Most of the research on how children
learn to read has been on monolingual children, some on ESL children, and very
little on Aboriginal children. Starting with the collection of some baseline
data, we investigated whether Aboriginal children in grade one are at risk of
school failure? And if so, to what extent? Sixty-five first grade children (33
boys and 32 girls) were asked to complete the Group Reading Assessment and
Diagnostic Evaluation (GRA+DE), (Form A), Level K, (Williams, 2001). Level K is
designed for kindergarten, early first grade, and transitional first-grade
classrooms. There are eight subtests that measure early reading skills - sound
matching, rhyming, same and different words, print awareness, letter
recognition, phoneme-grapheme correspondence, and listening comprehension. On
average, the Aboriginal grade one children studied are at risk of school
failure. They perform more than 1SD below the norm for other children in their
age group. Stated another way, approximately 95% of the children in the
reference group scored higher on the GRA+DE than did the Aboriginal children we
studied. The first two subtests (sound matching and rhyming) comprise the
phonological awareness dimension and neither requires any print recognition.
Sound matching measures the child's ability to hear like sounds at either the
beginning or the end of a word and rhyming measures the child's ability to hear
matching common phonograms. Listening comprehension and phoneme-grapheme
dimensions were found to be relative strengths for the Aboriginal children
while significant weaknesses were noted in phonological and early literacy
skills. To the best of our knowledge, our study is the first dedicated to
understanding reading development among Canadian Aboriginal children and our results
certainly force us to look to the underlying beliefs, attitudes and
expectations that Aboriginals hold about literacy, to the methods we use to
assess literacy, and to the ways in which literacy development may be enhanced.
These considerations are essential to an inclusive and consistent educational
system for all Canadians.
Erin Phinney (University of Denver), Ashley Scott, Michelle Shanahan, P.
Antonio Olmos-Gallo, Richard Boada, and Bruce F. Pennington. Neuroanatomical correlates of reading ability.
Brain structures implicated in dyslexia vary greatly across structural MRI
studies, possibly due to small sample sizes. The current study, with 162
subjects, is the largest known study to examine brain volume differences
relating to reading ability. Individual regression analyses on 7 neo-cortical
and 5 sub-cortical brain structures indicated a significant effect of reading
ability on thalamic volume, and a trend towards significance for white matter
volume, after accounting for age, FSIQ and gender. Implications for the
relationship between anatomical findings and behavioral phenotype will be
discussed.
Victoria Purcell-Gates (Michigan State University), Nell K. Duke. Explicit teaching of genre as a means to improve comprehension and
composition of non-narrative text. This
paper reports the results of a two-year study of two approaches to teaching
reading and writing of informational and procedural text in second- and
third-grade science. Both approaches included authentic reading and writing of
informational and procedural text within science instruction; one approach also
included explicit teaching of the functions and features of these genres.
Classes (N = 16) were randomly assigned to condition and students'
comprehension and composition of the target genres was measured up to six
times. Results speak to the efficacy of explicit teaching of genre as a means
to improve young children's comprehension and composition.
Pieter Reitsma (PI
Research, VU Amsterdam). Orthographic
learning in children with epilepsia or dyslexia. Degree
of orthographic learning after the reading of real stories was assessed in
normal Dutch beginning readers, and in two groups of children matched on
reading ability: children with epilepsia, and children with dyslexia. New names
were introduced in the stories and these names could be spelled homophonically
in two alternate ways (e.g. Darein - Darijn). The number of times one of these
spellings occurred was systematically varied. Orthographic choice, naming
times, and spelling data for the target words were determined after reading the
stories. Significant differences among groups were found showing that dyslexics
are specifically delayed in orthographic learning.
Cara Richards (University
of California, Santa Barbara), and Jill Leafstedt. A microgenetic analysis of phonological development in English. This paper will demonstrate the relationship between
the spelling abilities of young English Learners (EL) and their phonological
processing and decoding abilities. Two spelling measures, a recognition task
and a production task, were given to 193 EL in Southern California. Results
indicate that phonological awareness contributes to EL abilities to spell and
the spelling productions of these students provide information about their
phonological awareness abilities and their development in these skills as they
crossover to English Literacy.
Jeremiah Ring (Texas
Scottish Rite Hospital for Children), and Jeffrey L. Black. An investigation of individual treatment
response in an alphabetic phonics intervention for reading difficulties. Recent reading intervention research has examined the
interaction of student aptitudes with instruction in an effort to identify
factors that can account for observed variability in treatment response. This
study adds to that literature by examining reading development in a group of
children attending a two-year long, Orton-Gillingham based reading program
administered by their respective schools. Previously reported results from the
midtest assessments of this sample found that students with lower baseline
skill levels showed the largest gains after one year of instruction. The
analyses reported in this paper of new data collected after a second treatment
year evaluates the overall effectiveness of the intervention and examines
whether the pattern of correlation observed at midtest replicates at posttest.
Kristen D. Ritchey
(Rutgers University). Developmental
spelling: A comparison of two scoring systems. Although
children in kindergarten are unlikely to spell complete words correctly,
analysis of what children can spell can provide information about the
development of phonological awareness and reading-related skills. This study
compares the developmental spelling procedure proposed by Tangel and Blachman
(1992, 1995) to correct-letter sequence scoring (Tindal & Marston, 1990)
commonly used in curriculum-based measurement. This study analyzes the spelling
of 94 kindergarten children and compares the relationship of the scores
calculated from each method to phonological awareness and reading-related
knowledge outcomes. An empirical investigation is necessary before one scoring
system can be recommended over the other.
Javier S. Sainz (Universidad
Complutense de Madrid), Carmen Villalba, Guillermo de Jorge Botana, and Petroula
Mousikou. Conjoining letters into words:
Attention- and lexicon-based effects on the comission of lexical errors. Ordinary adult readers participated in two word visual
recognition experiments aimed at controlling attention-based and lexicon-based
effects. In these experiments subjects were first presented with a two-stimuli
display and then required to chose a postcued visual target among a set of
distractors while ERPs measures were taken, all items controlled by lexical
neighborhood size (i.e. high density vs low density according to neighborhood
size), frequency and semantic relatedness. In the first experiment, a target
word (e.g., VACA, i.e. COW) was to be chosen following an associate (TORO, i.e.
BULL) from a response set formed by an homophonic unrelated word (BACA, i.e.
RACK), a similar unrelated word (LACA, i.e. RESIN) and a partially similar
pseudoword (GACA). The target word was displayed and masked under different
conditions. In the second experiment, a target word (e.g., COSTE, i.e. COST)
was to be chosen following an associate (e.g. GASTO, i.e. EXPENSE) from a
response set formed by an unrelated word (CESTO, i.e. BASKET) made of the same
letters from the target word in different order, a similar unrelated word
(RESTO, i.e. REMAINDER) and a partially similar pseudoword (TOCES). The data
from the two experiments seem not to be totally compatible with the notion that
phonological constraints on lexical access precede and set the stage for
orthographic constraints.
Donna M. Scanlon
(University of Albany), Frank R. Vellutino, Sheila Small, Joan Sweeney, and
Diane Fanuele. The short and long term
effects of different types of early literacy intervention on reading
comprehension. This paper
will report on the comprehension performance of groups of children who received
one of two types of early literacy intervention: one in which the primary focus
was on developing phonological coding skills and one in which the primary focus
was on engaging the children in reading connected text and developing a strategic
approach to reading connected text - using both meaning and phonologically
based strategies to identify unfamiliar words. The children's performance on a
standardized measure of reading comprehension was measured at the end of the
intervention period (Grade 1) and at the end of second and third grade.
Hollis S. Scarborough (Haskins Laboratories), Anne H. Charity, and Darion Griffin. Linguistic challenges for young readers. The form and content of the language used at school –
in classroom instruction and in written materials — can differ markedly from the more colloquial language a child is
exposed to outside of school. New evidence will be presented to illustrate
these differences and to examine relationships between children’s knowledge of
school language and their reading achievement in Pre-K, K, and Grade 1.
Michal Shany (Haifa
University), and Ilana Ben-Dror. Surface
and phonological reading: Further evidence from Hebrew orthography. Last year we presented a pilot study that investigated
the manifestation of sub-types of reading disabilities in Hebrew orthography.
We found the Hebrew orthography as a unique opportunity to study the subtypes
issue by analyzing the reading performance of the same subjects dealing with
the same orthography that varies along the orthographic depth characteristic,
meaning: shallow/deep characteristic of the relation between orthography and
phonology. In our paper we presented last year data based on reading
performance of sixth grade disabled readers, and found evidence of two
sub-types of reading disabilities. These results were different than results
usually reported for shallow orthographies, such as German. Our results
resembled the general pattern of sub-types observed in English orthography, but
provided specific symptoms that characterized the Hebrew orthography. This year
we would like to extend the previous data. Our first intention is to try and
replicate the data that were presented last year only on the basis of clinical
sample. In addition we intend to study how early in reading development these
two sub-groups can be reliably identified? Such data can provide further
understanding of the specific characteristic of each orthography (In English
sub-types are reported for as early as second grade), as well as provide
further understanding of core deficit vs. developmental lag explanation of
reading disabilities. For this purpose we are analyzing reading performance of
3 reading disabled groups: second grade, fourth grade and sixth grade, data are
taken from a representative national sample (1,600 subjects). This will be the
first study in Hebrew that is based on national sample. Data and discussion
will be presented in the conference.
Joseph Shimron (University
of Haifa), and Vered Vaknin. The dynamics
of reading instruction reform. During the
last decade or so a number of states have reformed or are in the process of
reforming their methods of reading instruction. In most cases the direction of
the reform is from a Whole Language to a Phonic Emphasized method. In this
presentation we focus on the conditions that make such a reform possible or
even successful. We describe one reform in which we were personally involved,
and in analyzing our experience, we suggest the conditions that, in our
opinion, must exist for the reform to take place. We also note that some
changes may be introduced in a relatively short time and with a little effort,
while others are much more difficult to achieve and their implementation may
take a long time.
Robindra Sidhu (Queen's
University), John Kirby, and Rauno Parilla. Visual-orthographic
pattern recognition in kindergarten children: Are there differential speed and
accuracy gains after a second exposure in double deficit subtypes? The present investigation examined visual-orthographic
pattern recognition in a sample of 214 kindergarten children categorized into
double deficit subtypes. Participants were exposed to a visual-orthographic
pattern (e.g. Tp) and were asked to identify it from a response-array of four
items (e.g., Tp, Tz, Qp ,Zp). Of interest was whether participants made
differential gains in accuracy and speed on a second exposure as a function of
their subtype classification. Only subtypes with a naming speed deficit made
gains in accuracy on a second exposure. Double deficit and double asset groups
made gains in speed, albeit for different reasons.
Linda Siegel (University
of British Columbia), and Nonie Lesaux. The
development of reading in children who speak English as a second language. The prevalence of reading failure is higher in
low-income populations, and in individuals with English as a second language
(ESL). The participants of the 5-year longitudinal study are all of the
children who entered kindergarten a school district. In kindergarten, all
children identified as at-risk for reading failure received intervention to
augment their pre-reading and language skills. The development of reading of
the participants from kindergarten to grade 4 was examined using individual
growth curves. The results show that it is possible to mediate the negative
effects of socioeconomic status and ESL status through early intervention for
at-risk children.
Louise Spear-Swerling (Southern Connecticut State University), and Pamela Owen Brucker. What affects novice teachers' knowledge base
about English word structure? This study
examined novice teachers' development of knowledge important for teaching word
identification and spelling. Novices’ knowledge about the structure of English
words increased significantly after instruction in a teacher-education course
and correlated significantly with certain measures of their reading-related
abilities, such as phonological skills. Struggling readers tutored by a
subgroup of the novice teachers improved significantly in specific reading and
spelling skills. The results suggest that teachers’ understanding of word
structure may be influenced by their own reading-related abilities, especially
in the absence of instruction, and that even short-term tutoring by novice
teachers can benefit struggling readers.
Rhona Stainthorp
(London University), and Diana Highes. Does
exceptionally early reading ability affect writing quality? This paper presents some evidence from a longitudinal
study of precocious readers. The data relate to an analysis of written narratives
produced by 14 children when they were 5-, 6-, and 11-years-old. The children
were identified as being precocious readers before they had started school.
Their performance is contrasted with that of an able group who had not been
precocious readers. The narratives provide useful evidence about developmental
changes in writing but data suggest that there were only limited positive
effects on vocabulary and written expression indicating that the relationship
between writing ability and reading is complex.
Kathy Stephenson
(University of Alberta), and Rauno Parrila. Effects
of cognitive and noncognitive factors on the acquisition of reading skills. The contributions of cognitive (nonverbal IQ,
vocabulary, and verbal STM) and noncognitive factors (home literacy practices,
parental beliefs and expectations and children’s achievement strategies) on
children’s precocious reading is examined. The questions addressed are: a) what
cognitive and noncognitive factors are uniquely associated with better preliteracy
skills (phonological sensitivity and naming speed), and (b) what cognitive,
noncognitive, and preliteracy skills are uniquely associated with precocious
reading. 78 children were assessed in kindergarten and again in grade 1. Their
parents filled out a questionnaire about home literacy practices, and about
their beliefs in their child’s cognitive ability and expectations for their
child’s education. Teachers rated the student’s achievement strategies.
John Evar Strid (Northwestern
University), and James R. Booth. The
effect of consonant, vowel and syllabic priming in Spanish and English. This study examined how the consistency of
orthographic and phonological mappings influenced bilingual readers’ early
processing during written word identification. We tested 24 English-Spanish
readers using a brief identification paradigm with consonant, vowel and
syllabic priming. We found that bilingual readers used priming information more
in Spanish than in English, especially for vowels and syllables. This suggests
(1) that vowel information in English may not play as large a role because of
the disproportionate inconsistency in grapheme-phoneme mappings for vowels and
(2) that the syllable may play a more important role in Spanish as a main
pre-lexical unit in word recognition.Ron Stringer (McGill University), Gail
McCoubrey, Malenie Gotlieb, Mariam Haider, Erin Beetham, Sharhezad Irranejad,
Lisa French, and Joan Wolforth. Assessment
practices in the diagnosis of reading disability in young adults. Two hundred learning disability assessment reports
were analysed. We looked at the rates of diagnosis of reading disability,
whether the assessment methods were appropriate to the detection of a reading
disability, and compared reports with diagnoses of reading disabilities to
reports with other diagnoses. Preliminary results indicate dramatic differences
from a similar sample analysed by McGuire et al. (1997). Where McGuire et al.
found a modal battery consisting of a single IQ test, our modal battery
consisted of 5 – 6 tests, including measures of IQ, general and specific
academic achievement, visuo-spatial processing and receptive vocabulary.
Carrie Szucs (Queen's
University), and Lesly Wade-Woolley. English
phonological development in early French immersion readers. The present study examines the development of English
phonological skills in students learning to read in French. In particular, this
study examines which English phonological skill (onset-rime or phoneme) is a
better predictor of reading development for French immersion students. Children
enrolled in the French immersion program were administered onset-rime, phoneme
and reading measures in kindergarten. These same measures were re-administered
in grade one. The findings are important because it will lead to better
understanding of the universal and language-specific aspects of phonological
development.
Yu-chi Tai (University
of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign), and George W. McConkie. Hazard curves reveal individual differences in reading. Traditionally, readers’ eye movement characteristics
are represented by mean indices, including mean fixation duration and saccade
length. However, these indices lose much of the temporal information that is in
eye movement data. In contrast, hazard curves show changes in saccadic activity
over time. In this paper, we illustrate two ways in which fixation duration
hazard curves can reveal individual differences in the temporal characteristics
of processing in normal and dyslexic readers.
Verena Thaler (University
of Salzburg), Karin Landerl, and Heinz Wimmer. Spelling pronunciations as a means of remediating spelling deficits. Aim of our study was to develop and evaluate a
computerised program to improve orthographic spelling skills of dyslexic
children. Although German is highly consistent from graphemes to phonemes,
consistency in the other direction (phonemes to graphemes) is much lower so
that spelling patterns have to be stored in an orthographic lexicon. We trained
poor spellers to use spelling pronunciations, that is unnatural, hypercorrect
pronunciations including all letters of the word spelling, as an additional
multi-sensory code to memorize orthographically correct spellings. In a first
empirical assessment of this concept we did not find a specific effect of
spelling pronunciations over and above a standard word-specific spelling
training.
G. Brian Thompson
(Victoria University of Wellington), Vincent Connelly, Claire M.
Fletcher-Flinn, and Sheryl J. Hodson. Effects
of childhood phonics instruction persist as a phonemic awareness advantage in
adulthood but a lexicalized recoding disadvantage. This is a study of long-term effects of childhood
phonics instruction. Two adult samples were compared. One had attended schools
with explicit phonics and the other, schools without. The phonics sample was
more proficient in isolated letter-sound responses and in phonemic
segmentation. The nonphonics sample gave more correct responses to pseudowords,
due to their greater accuracy on pseudowords with lexical rimes that always
have irregular spellings. The phonics sample regularized these pseudowords. The
implication is that theories of the skilled reading process cannot avoid taking
account of the instructional history of the reader.
Rolando D. Tiu (Case
Western Reserve University), Douglas K. Detterman, and Lee A. Thompson. Exploring the impact of genes and
environment on scholastic achievement measures as a function of parental
education. An earlier
report from the Western Reserve Twin Project (WRTP) has suggested that the
heritability of general cognitive ability is higher when the father’s
educational level is higher. The impact of the shared environment is higher
when the father’s educational level is lower. The current report will extend
these analyses to measures of scholastic achievement. Using the DF approach
developed by DeFries and Fulker, heritability and shared family environment
were calculated for specific cognitive abilities and for scholastic achievement
and tested for significant changes across levels of parental education and
occupational status.
Joanna K. Uhry (Fordham
University). Teachers' phonemic knowledge
and skills and first graders' reading outcomes. A
number of studies have looked at teachers’ knowledge of the phonemic structure
of oral language (Moats, 1994; McCutchen, Harry, Cunningham, Cox, Sidman, &
Covill, 2002; Scarborough, Ehri, Olson, & Fowler, 1998; Uhry, 2001).
Because phonemic awareness (PA) is so important to the acquisition of beginning
reading (Adams, 1990), it is an assumption in the literature that teachers’
knowledge of PA will benefit the children they teach. The present study, in
process, of 27 certified teachers working in one-to-one tutoring twice a week
with Grade 1 students is examining teachers’ knowledge of phonological
processes as well as at their actual ability to carry out effective PA lessons.
Videotaped lessons are being coded in regard to teachers’ ability to match PA
instruction to their student’s PA level and to modify instruction based on
student response. Correlations will look at relationships with student
outcomes.
Victor van Daal (University
of Wales Bangor). Item-specificity and
the role of neighbours in orthography learning. Several
views have been put forward on how orthographic knowledge is acquired. In
particular, the notion of item-specific learning (Share, 1995) seems hard to be
reconciled with transfer effects (the role of ‘friends’ and ‘enemies’ in the
orthographic lexicon (e.g., Stuart, Masterson, Dixon & Quinlan, 1999). We
also did not find effects of neighbourhood frequency in the learning of
nonwords (SSSR 2002). We hypothesise that for initial learning the
neighbourhood frequency is not of relevance, but neighbours will play an
increasing facilitating role with repeated presentations of the nonwords. An
experiment will be presented which supports this hypothesis.
Sophie van der Sluis (University of Amsterdam), Peter F. de Jong, and Aryan van der Leij. Working memory capacity in children with
reading and arithmetic disabilities. There
tends to be considerable co-morbidity between reading and arithmetic
disabilities. In this study, we examined working memory deficits in children
with reading disability, arithmetic disability, and both disabilities.
Following the working memory model of Baddeley and Hitch, tasks were selected
to reflect the central executive, the phonological loop and the visuo-spatial
sketch pad. The results indicated that reading disabled children had deficits
in the phonological loop and the central executive. Arithmetic disabled
children showed deficits on the central executive. The pattern of deficits in
children with both learning disabilities was a combination of the deficits
found in singly disabled.
Connie K. Varnhagen
(University of Alberta), Angela Chamberland, Morgan Willson, Lauren Figueredo,
and Trudy Kwong. Brain activation during
spelling. We examined
brain regions involved in phonological, orthographic, and visual processes
related to spelling using functional magnetic resonance imaging. Twelve
right-handed, monolingual English-speaking males between the ages of 18-22
participated. Our experimental tasks were phonological choice (sheap-shead),
orthographic choice (beff-ffeb), and visual choice (sleep-sleap) and our
control task was letter choice (xlpft-#$?!). Each experimental task was presented
in eight, 20 sec blocks alternating with the control task. Our preliminary
results show similar regions but different levels of activation; we found
greater left inferior frontal activation (BA 38, 48) for the phonological task
and greater left right inferior and middle frontal (BA 45,44) and left fusiform
activation for the orthographic task.
Ludo Verhoeven (University
of Nijmegen), and Jan van Leeuwe. Growth
of word decoding skills throughout primary school: The case of Dutch. The paper presents a longitudinal study on the
development of word decoding over grade 1-6 in primary school in the
Netherlands. A word decoding test was administered with 1812 native Dutch
children and 331 minority children. The test consisted of three subtests
addressing different orthographic word patterns: CVC-words, monosyllabic words
with consonant clusters and polysyllabic words. The results showed a quadratic
growth model fitting the data better than a linear model. The three word
decoding subskills were highly interrelated, leaving some unique variance for
the three types of orthographic patterns. The relation between speed and
accuracy turned out to be similar for children varying in decoding skills.
Girls did better on the tests than boys with no differences between first and
second language learners. Word blending and letter knowledge turned out to be
substantial predictors of word decoding development.
Rose Vukovic (University
of British Columbia), Nonie Lesaux, and Linda Siegel. An investigation of the double-deficit hypothesis in a longitudinal
study of reading development. The double
deficit hypothesis of dyslexia posits three subtypes of impaired reader: those
with a singular deficit in phonological processing, those with a singular
deficit in naming speed, and those with a double deficit. In a longitudinal (k
to grade 4) investigation of reading development, there was no support for the
double-deficit hypothesis as we were unable to identify any dyslexic children
with a singular naming speed deficit. Results reveal that naming speed
contributes only modestly to reading ability by the end of grade 4, and when
working memory is included in the analyses, naming speed does not contribute
significantly.
Lesly Wade-Woolley
(Queen's University), and S. Hélène Deacon. Canadian
spelling, eh? Bilingual children’s morphological awareness and their use of
morphological information. This
presentation will report on the third year of a longitudinal study of the
spelling development of English-speaking children in French immersion. We examined
morphemic spellings (e.g., ed in English and er in French) and morphological
awareness in both languages. Earlier results suggested strong connections
between morphological awareness and spelling in each language. These new data
will test the strength of these relations by examining pseudo-words. Further,
spellings will be examined for the use of phonological, orthographic and
morphological information. These results will be discussed in relation to
current models of spelling development and transfer processes in biliteracy.
Lesly Wade-Woolley (Symposium Covenor) (Queen's University), and researchers from the
Canadian Language and Literacy Research Network (CLLRNet). Symposium: Linguistic Diversity in Reading Development: The Canadian
Context.Canada has enjoyed a
reputation as a country that welcomes linguistic diversity. As a result,
Canadian children learning to read have many different faces. Some speak one of
our two official languages, French and English, and are learning to read in
their mother tongue. Others, whose mother tongue, English, is the dominant
language in North America, are learning to read in enrichment contexts, and
receive formal schooling in a second language. Still others are visible
minorities and come from lower socioeconomic families, which place them at risk
for reading failure; these children may speak English as a second language
and/or be Aboriginal children. Canadian researchers studying reading
development have located their research within these populations. Their findings
address issues that are germane to Canadian children learning to read, but more
importantly, they contribute to our broader theories of reading acquisition by
examining cognitive, linguistic and cultural variables through cross linguistic
and second language investigations. The papers in this session are submitted by
researchers from the Canadian Language and Literacy Research Network (CLLRNet)
to address issues in reading acquisition that are pertinent in the Canadian
context, but have wider application to the field of reading research. The
Network is a federally-funded National Centre of Excellence dedicated to
research in language and literacy issues. CLLRNet includes researchers across
the country organized across multi-disciplinary themes (biological factors;
sensory processes & environments; language; literacy; social,economic &
program influences) to work on collaborative projects focusing on normal and
atypical language and literacy development. The papers in the current symposium
focus on issues in reading development which are relevant to all researchers in
our field. Geva and Yagoubzadeh pursue the cognitive and linguistic predictors
of fluent reading in ESL children. Cormier et al. show that phonological
characteristics of spoken French demand that syllable awareness as well as
phoneme awareness play roles in reading French. Phillips et al. report a study
of reading acquisition in aboriginal children that considers how phonological
awareness measures interact with cultural factors. Finally, in a study of
English-speaking children in French Immersion, Jared et al. investigate the
role of first (L1) and second (L2) language oral proficiency measured in
kindergarten in the development of grade one reading. This collection of papers
build around a theme of linguistic diversity; while the particulars of the
studies are specific to the Canadian population, the findings contribute to our
larger knowledge of reading development in a diverse world.
Min Wang (University
of Maryland), Ying Liu, Charles A. Perfetti, and Natalie Flynn. Chinese-English biliteracy acquisition:
Cross language and writing system transfer. Recent
research on biliteracy development of children learning to read English, an
alphabetic writing system from another alphabetic system such as Spanish has
yielded consistent results on the strong facilitation between first (L1) and
second language (L2) reading skills. The present study was aimed to investigate
such development of children learning to read English from an orthographically
and typologically different writing system - Chinese. About 30 Mandarin
speaking Chinese children were tested for their L1 and L2 language and reading
skills at grade 2. The key component skills that were examined included oral
proficiency, phonological processing, word identification, and reading
comprehension. Children's non-verbal cognitive skills were also tested.
Relationships between L1 and L2 skills were analyzed. The specific skills that
were transferred were identified based on the similarities and differences
between L1 and L2. These findings provide insight into the interaction between
universal and language-specific processes of biliteracy development.
Gareth J. Williams
(Open University), Clare Wood, and Dorothy Faulkner. Multi-modal temporal order judgments in typically developing children,
children with dyslexia and children with dyspraxia. Previous research has indicated that children with
dyslexia and children with developmental coordination disorder (DCD) may share
a common deficit that may be related to temporal processing. Ten children with
dyslexia, ten children with DCD and ten controls, aged between nine and 14 were
tested on a number of baseline tests and a multi-modal temporal order judgement
task where they were required to reproduce the order of either auditory or
visual stimuli, some of which were phonological or orthographic in nature. The
data are expected to indicate different profiles of temporal order judgement
deficits in both dyslexia and DCD compared to controls.
Joanna P. Williams
(Teachers College, Columbia University), K. Brooke Stafford, Kendra Hall,
Kristen D. Lauer, Laura DeSisto, and John S. deCani. Improving the comprehension of informational text via text structure
instruction for at-risk second graders. This
study replicated and extended a study that investigated the effectiveness of an
instructional program designed to teach the comprehension of compare/contrast
expository texts, a program that emphasized text structure while also
introducing new content. Compared to more traditional instruction that
emphasized only content and to no instruction, the program improved students’
ability to comprehend compare/contrast expository text. Students were able to
demonstrate transfer of this knowledge to uninstructed compare/contrast texts,
including authentic text. In last year’s study, students were not able to
transfer this knowledge to a text structure, pro/con, that was not addressed in
the instruction. This year a limited amount of pro/con instruction was
incorporated into the program and showed a small positive effect. Findings
indicate that text structure instruction can improve second graders’
comprehension of expository text and that such instruction does not detract
from their ability to learn new content.
Kathleen M. Wilson
(University of Nebraska, Lincoln), and Guy Trainin. Blossoming literacy: Early readers' self-system and achievement. This study examined the relationships between literacy
achievement and self-system components in 198 first graders. Using the Early
Literacy Motivation Scale, we measured self-efficacy / perceived competence and
attributions related to reading, writing, and spelling. Findings showed that
first graders did not differentiate among the three literacy tasks. Using a
temporal sequence latent path model, we found that students with low literacy
achievement showed a greater relationship between the self-system and their
literacy performance than students who displayed an average or high performance
on literacy tasks. Additionally, there was no feedback loop in which the
self-system components added unique variance to consequent achievement.Gwen E. Wolters (University Leiden), Wim Van den
Broeck, and Wied Ruijssenaars. Subsyllabic
processing in Dutch beginning readers: In search of a role for bigram
frequency. The role of subsyllabic
processing in reading development has been explored in various ways. One way of
investigating this is to take language characteristics into consideration. In
this Experiment we examined whether bigram frequency influenced reading speed
and accuracy in Dutch beginning readers. Results indicate that bigram frequency
does influence reading speed and accuracy. Also, data showed that this
frequency effect tended to play another role at different reading levels.
Clare Wood (Open
University). A longitudinal study of
spoken word recognition, temporal information processing awareness and
literacy. This paper
will evaluate whether spoken word recognition or temporal information
processing measures are able to predict children's phonemic awareness and
literacy development. It will also consider whether children who showed
difficulties in rapid processing on a temporal order judgement task were
significantly worse at phonemic awareness, reading, and spelling than their
peers. Children were assessed in pre-school and during their first four years
in school on their phonological awareness, temporal order judgment, spoken word
recognition, and literacy attainment. Data collection will finish in May 2003,
and the results of the study as a whole will be presented.
Yolanda W. S. Yuen
(Queen's University), and Lesly Wade-Woolley. Phonological processing in Chinese reading. Phonological processing has been shown to be important
in alphabetic languages. However, until recently, researchers believe that
visual skills are more important in Chinese reading acquisition. An increasing
number of studies have demonstrated that phonological information is important
in learning to read in English. The present study investigates the role of
phonological processing in Chinese, and assesses the contribution of each
component in phonological processing in Chinese reading. From the result of the
present study, educators can better tailor the Chinese reading acquisition
instructions to emphasize the most important component in phonological
processing, if phonological processing does play a significant role in Chinese
reading acquisition.